QMBL lists 17 published ground-state energies for the spin-1/2 Heisenberg antiferromagnet (kagome 12x12 (432 sites), periodic boundaries). The best variational energy is -0.432519(1), by VMC (Gutzwiller) in Iqbal et al. (2014); and the best extrapolated energy is -0.43652(4), by VMC (Gutzwiller) in Iqbal et al. (2014). QMBL has no exact energy for this instance. Energies as E/N (S.S).
How these numbers were read
Where each number below was read, and how it was checked.
-0.43652(4), VMC (Gutzwiller)
Checked 2026-11-12 · source text of arXiv:1311.5038 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-12)
Reported as. −0.43652(4)
Table I, row 432, column 'Ground state': zero-variance extrapolation, 'only two points have been used for the 432-site cluster' (Fig. 3 caption); sources/1311.5038.txt line 70; version read: arXiv text (sources/1311.5038.txt, pypdf layout mode); journal version not read in this reading (it was read in the second reading of 2026-11-16) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). Plausibility (1311.5038): the 0-LS and 1-LS energies lie above the best variational energy on 192 sites (-0.435949) and decrease with p, as variational energies must; the zero-variance value -0.43652(4) is an estimate, not a bound, and lies 2.2e-4 above the 192-site zero-variance estimate of the same table (-0.43674(3)).
-0.432519(1), VMC (Gutzwiller)
Checked 2026-11-12 · source text of arXiv:1311.5038 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-12)
Reported as. −0.432519(1)
Table I, row 432, column 1-LS (one Lanczos step on the Dirac state); sources/1311.5038.txt line 70; version read: arXiv text (sources/1311.5038.txt, pypdf layout mode); journal version not read in this reading (it was read in the second reading of 2026-11-16) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). Plausibility: every value lies above the 192-site variational records (about -0.4359) and, for the Dirac state, within 1e-4 of its 192-site value (-0.4286749), as a gapless state's energy should.
-0.4287266(4), VMC (Gutzwiller)
Checked 2026-11-12 · source text of arXiv:1712.04579 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-12)
Reported as. −0.4287266(4)
Supplemental Material Table S2, row J▽/J∆ = 1.0 (isotropic kagome), column 432; sources/1712.04579.txt line 530; version read: arXiv text (sources/1712.04579.txt, pypdf layout mode); journal version not read in this reading (it was read in the second reading of 2026-11-16) | Eq. (1): H = J∆ sum_∆ S_i.S_j + J▽ sum_▽ S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators; at J▽/J∆ = 1.0 the nearest-neighbour kagome Heisenberg model; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). Plausibility: every value lies above the 192-site variational records (about -0.4359) and, for the Dirac state, within 1e-4 of its 192-site value (-0.4286749), as a gapless state's energy should.
-0.42872(1), VMC (Gutzwiller)
Checked 2026-11-18 · source text of arXiv:1105.0341 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-18)
Reported as. −0.42872(1)
page 3, 'For the present cluster, these values are E/J = −0.42872(1) per site, and χ2 = −0.0186(2)' (the [0,π; 0,π] state, nearest-neighbour Hamiltonian); the same value is printed for the 576-site cluster in arXiv:1011.3954, a row there; sources/1105.0341.txt line 182; version read: Phys. Rev. B 84, 020407(R) publisher PDF (2026-11-16) and its Supplemental Material (2026-11-18), values identical to the arXiv text | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). The spin Hamiltonian is periodic; the mixed periodic-antiperiodic boundary conditions are those of the fermionic mean-field state before projection. Plausibility: every value lies above the instance's best variational energy, -0.432519 per site (1-LS VMC, arXiv:1311.5038).
-0.4287114(3), VMC (Gutzwiller)
Checked 2026-11-12 · source text of arXiv:1712.04579 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-12)
Reported as. −0.4287114(3)
Supplemental Material Table S1, row J▽/J∆ = 1.0 (isotropic kagome), column 432; sources/1712.04579.txt line 509; version read: arXiv text (sources/1712.04579.txt, pypdf layout mode); journal version not read in this reading (it was read in the second reading of 2026-11-16) | Eq. (1): H = J∆ sum_∆ S_i.S_j + J▽ sum_▽ S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators; at J▽/J∆ = 1.0 the nearest-neighbour kagome Heisenberg model; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). Plausibility: every value lies above the 192-site variational records (about -0.4359) and, for the Dirac state, within 1e-4 of its 192-site value (-0.4286749), as a gapless state's energy should.
-0.428656(1), VMC (Gutzwiller)
Checked 2026-11-12 · source text of arXiv:1311.5038 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-12)
Reported as. −0.428656(1)
Table I, row 432, column 0-LS (Gutzwiller-projected U(1) Dirac spin liquid); sources/1311.5038.txt line 70; version read: arXiv text (sources/1311.5038.txt, pypdf layout mode); journal version not read in this reading (it was read in the second reading of 2026-11-16) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). Plausibility: every value lies above the 192-site variational records (about -0.4359) and, for the Dirac state, within 1e-4 of its 192-site value (-0.4286749), as a gapless state's energy should.
-0.42863(2), VMC (Gutzwiller)
Checked 2026-11-12 · source text of arXiv:1105.0341 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-12)
Reported as. −0.42863(2)
page 3, 'Its energy per site is E/J = −0.42863(2)' for the nearest-neighbour U(1) Dirac spin liquid on the 432-site cluster ('on a 432-site cluster with mixed periodic-antiperiodic boundary conditions', lines 125-126); sources/1105.0341.txt line 136; version read: arXiv text (sources/1105.0341.txt, pypdf layout mode); journal version not read in this reading (it was read in the second reading of 2026-11-16) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). Plausibility: every value lies above the 192-site variational records (about -0.4359) and, for the Dirac state, within 1e-4 of its 192-site value (-0.4286749), as a gapless state's energy should.
-0.42853(2), VMC (Gutzwiller)
Checked 2026-11-18 · source text of arXiv:cond-mat/0611414 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-18)
Reported as. −0.42853(2)
Table III, row 'chiral spin liquid (θ = 0.05)', column 12x12x3 lattice ('energy per site in unit of J for possible' instabilities of the U(1)-Dirac state); sources/cond-mat-0611414.txt line 163; version read: Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117205 publisher PDF (2026-11-18, Tables I and III identical to the arXiv text) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). The spin Hamiltonian is periodic; the mixed periodic-antiperiodic boundary conditions are those of the fermionic mean-field state before projection. Plausibility: every value lies above the instance's best variational energy, -0.432519 per site (1-LS VMC, arXiv:1311.5038).
-0.42846(2), VMC (Gutzwiller)
Checked 2026-11-18 · source text of arXiv:cond-mat/0611414 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-18)
Reported as. −0.42846(2)
Table III, row 'VBS state (|χ1/χ2| = 0.95)', column 12x12x3 lattice ('energy per site in unit of J for possible' instabilities of the U(1)-Dirac state); sources/cond-mat-0611414.txt line 161; version read: Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117205 publisher PDF (2026-11-18, Tables I and III identical to the arXiv text) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). The spin Hamiltonian is periodic; the mixed periodic-antiperiodic boundary conditions are those of the fermionic mean-field state before projection. Plausibility: every value lies above the instance's best variational energy, -0.432519 per site (1-LS VMC, arXiv:1311.5038).
-0.42844(2), VMC (Gutzwiller)
Checked 2026-11-18 · source text of arXiv:cond-mat/0611414 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-18)
Reported as. −0.42844(2)
Table III, row 'VBS state (|χ1/χ2| = 1.05)', column 12x12x3 lattice ('energy per site in unit of J for possible' instabilities of the U(1)-Dirac state); sources/cond-mat-0611414.txt line 159; version read: Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117205 publisher PDF (2026-11-18, Tables I and III identical to the arXiv text) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). The spin Hamiltonian is periodic; the mixed periodic-antiperiodic boundary conditions are those of the fermionic mean-field state before projection. Plausibility: every value lies above the instance's best variational energy, -0.432519 per site (1-LS VMC, arXiv:1311.5038).
-0.412308(1), VMC (RVB)
Checked 2026-11-18 · source text of arXiv:1105.0341 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-18)
Reported as. −0.412308(1)
Supplemental Material p. 1, same sentence, the extended 3rd n.n. [0, 0] SL (the main text, page 4: 'the 3rd NN uniform RVB SL with optimized χ2 and χ′3s'); journal Supplemental Material prints the same sentence; sources/1105.0341.txt line 318; version read: Phys. Rev. B 84, 020407(R) publisher PDF (2026-11-16) and its Supplemental Material (2026-11-18), values identical to the arXiv text | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). The spin Hamiltonian is periodic; the mixed periodic-antiperiodic boundary conditions are those of the fermionic mean-field state before projection. Plausibility: every value lies above the instance's best variational energy, -0.432519 per site (1-LS VMC, arXiv:1311.5038).
-0.41228(1), VMC (RVB)
Checked 2026-11-18 · source text of arXiv:1105.0341 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-18)
Reported as. −0.41228(1)
Supplemental Material p. 1, 'The energies of the NN [0, 0] SL and the extended 2nd and 3rd n.n. [0, 0] SLs ... are E/J = −0.41216(1), E/J = −0.41228(1), E/J = −0.412308(1) respectively' (the 2nd-neighbour state is the [0, 0;π,π] state of the main text, page 4); journal Supplemental Material (Supp-material.pdf and .tex, APS) prints the same sentence; sources/1105.0341.txt line 318; version read: Phys. Rev. B 84, 020407(R) publisher PDF (2026-11-16) and its Supplemental Material (2026-11-18), values identical to the arXiv text | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). The spin Hamiltonian is periodic; the mixed periodic-antiperiodic boundary conditions are those of the fermionic mean-field state before projection. Plausibility: every value lies above the instance's best variational energy, -0.432519 per site (1-LS VMC, arXiv:1311.5038).
-0.41216(1), VMC (RVB)
Checked 2026-11-12 · source text of arXiv:1105.0341 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-12)
Reported as. −0.41216(1)
page 3, 'its energy per site is E/J = −0.41216(1)' for the nearest-neighbour uniform RVB state [0, 0] on the same 432-site cluster; the sentence cites refs. 18 and 19 (Ran, Hermele, Lee & Wen, PRL 98, 117205; Hermele et al., PRB 77, 224413); Ran et al. print this state on the same 12x12x3 cluster only as −0.4121(1), so the five-digit value is kept as this paper's (ruled 2026-11-16); arXiv:1203.3421 credits −0.41216(1) to Ran et al. (its Ref. [32]); sources/1105.0341.txt line 144; version read: arXiv text (sources/1105.0341.txt, pypdf layout mode); journal version not read in this reading (it was read in the second reading of 2026-11-16) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). Plausibility: every value lies above the 192-site variational records (about -0.4359) and, for the Dirac state, within 1e-4 of its 192-site value (-0.4286749), as a gapless state's energy should.
-0.4121(1), VMC (RVB)
Checked 2026-11-18 · source text of arXiv:cond-mat/0611414 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-18)
Reported as. −0.4121(1)
Table I, row uniform RVB SL-[0, 0], column 12x12x3 lattice ('For all candidate projected spin-liquids, we list the energy per site in unit of J'); sources/cond-mat-0611414.txt line 99; version read: Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117205 publisher PDF (2026-11-18, Tables I and III identical to the arXiv text) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). The spin Hamiltonian is periodic; the mixed periodic-antiperiodic boundary conditions are those of the fermionic mean-field state before projection. Plausibility: every value lies above the instance's best variational energy, -0.432519 per site (1-LS VMC, arXiv:1311.5038).
-0.4010(1), VMC (Gutzwiller)
Checked 2026-11-18 · source text of arXiv:cond-mat/0611414 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-18)
Reported as. −0.4010(1)
Table I, row SL-[π/2, 0], column 12x12x3 lattice ('For all candidate projected spin-liquids, we list the energy per site in unit of J'); sources/cond-mat-0611414.txt line 93; version read: Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117205 publisher PDF (2026-11-18, Tables I and III identical to the arXiv text) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). The spin Hamiltonian is periodic; the mixed periodic-antiperiodic boundary conditions are those of the fermionic mean-field state before projection. Plausibility: every value lies above the instance's best variational energy, -0.432519 per site (1-LS VMC, arXiv:1311.5038).
-0.3910(1), VMC (Gutzwiller)
Checked 2026-11-18 · source text of arXiv:cond-mat/0611414 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-18)
Reported as. −0.3910(1)
Table I, row SL-[±π/2, 0], column 12x12x3 lattice ('For all candidate projected spin-liquids, we list the energy per site in unit of J'); sources/cond-mat-0611414.txt line 95; version read: Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117205 publisher PDF (2026-11-18, Tables I and III identical to the arXiv text) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). The spin Hamiltonian is periodic; the mixed periodic-antiperiodic boundary conditions are those of the fermionic mean-field state before projection. Plausibility: every value lies above the instance's best variational energy, -0.432519 per site (1-LS VMC, arXiv:1311.5038).
-0.3822(1), VMC (Gutzwiller)
Checked 2026-11-18 · source text of arXiv:cond-mat/0611414 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-18)
Reported as. −0.3822(1)
Table I, row SL-[π/2, π], column 12x12x3 lattice ('For all candidate projected spin-liquids, we list the energy per site in unit of J'); sources/cond-mat-0611414.txt line 97; version read: Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117205 publisher PDF (2026-11-18, Tables I and III identical to the arXiv text) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). The spin Hamiltonian is periodic; the mixed periodic-antiperiodic boundary conditions are those of the fermionic mean-field state before projection. Plausibility: every value lies above the instance's best variational energy, -0.432519 per site (1-LS VMC, arXiv:1311.5038).