QMBLthe quantum many-body leaderboard

All 322 instances

One page per Hamiltonian instance, at a stable URL, listing every published energy for it. 182 instances have a record; the rest say why they do not.

Heisenberg#

96 instances, 31 with a record, energies as E/N (S.S)

instancerecordmethodrows
chain, 20 sites, open -0.4341237DMRG (max truncation error ~ 1.0E-12) run script, no paper cited5
chain, 20 sites -0.4452193DMRG (max truncation error ~ 1.0E-13) run script, no paper cited7
chain, 200 sites, open -0.4422078DMRG (max truncation error ~ 1.0E-14) run script, no paper cited3
chain, 200 sites -0.4431678DMRG (max truncation error ~ 2.8E-12) run script, no paper cited4
kagome-24, 24 sites no recordsolved exactly1
kagome 2x2 (12 sites) no recordsolved exactly1
kagome 2x3 (18 sites) -0.4471262DMRG (bond dimension = 368) run script, no paper cited5
kagome-30, 30 sites no recordsolved exactly1
kagome-36a, 36 sites no recordsolved exactly1
kagome-36b, 36 sites no recordsolved exactly1
kagome-36c, 36 sites no recordsolved exactly1
kagome-36d, 36 sites no recordsolved exactly1
kagome-42a, 42 sites no recordsolved exactly1
kagome-42b, 42 sites no recordsolved exactly1
kagome 4x4 (48 sites) -0.4375(2)GCNN (6 layers, 6 feature maps), symmetric ansatz Đurić et al. (2024)4
kagome 6x6 (108 sites) no recordevery variational row is flagged2
kagome 8x8 (192 sites) -0.42987(1)VMC with Dirac spin liquid + Jastrow run script, no paper cited1
pyrochlore 2x2x2 (32 sites) -0.51627(2)mVMC with SU(2) and symmetry projections Astrakhantsev et al. (2021)3
pyrochlore 2x2x2 (128 sites) -0.49220(4)mVMC (PP + RBM + 1st step Lanczos, spin-parity... Pohle et al. (2023)1
pyrochlore 3x3x3 (108 sites) -0.48711(9)mVMC with SU(2) and symmetry projections Astrakhantsev et al. (2021)3
pyrochlore 3x3x3 (432 sites) -0.48847(3)mVMC (PP + 1st step Lanczos, spin-parity projection... Pohle et al. (2023)1
pyrochlore 4x4x4 (256 sites) -0.48310(7)mVMC with SU(2) and symmetry projections Astrakhantsev et al. (2021)2
pyrochlore 4x4x4 (1024 sites) -0.48800(1)mVMC (PP + 1st step Lanczos, spin-parity projection... Pohle et al. (2023)1
rectangular 10x20, periodic/open no recordsolved exactly1
rectangular 12x24, periodic/open no recordsolved exactly1
rectangular 14x28, periodic/open no recordsolved exactly1
rectangular 16x32, periodic/open no recordsolved exactly1
rectangular 18x36, periodic/open no recordsolved exactly1
rectangular 20x40, periodic/open no recordsolved exactly1
rectangular 24x48, periodic/open no recordsolved exactly1
rectangular 32x64, periodic/open no recordsolved exactly1
rectangular 48x96, periodic/open no recordsolved exactly1
rectangular 4x8, periodic/open no recordsolved exactly1
rectangular 64x128, periodic/open no recordsolved exactly1
rectangular 6x12, periodic/open no recordsolved exactly1
rectangular 6x8 no recordsolved exactly1
rectangular 8x16, periodic/open no recordsolved exactly1
shuriken, 24 sites no recordsolved exactly1
shuriken, 96 sites -0.43826(1)mVMC with SU(2) and point group projection Astrakhantsev et al. (2021)1
shuriken, 216 sites -0.4376(1)mVMC with SU(2) and point group projection Astrakhantsev et al. (2021)1
shuriken, 384 sites -0.4371(1)mVMC with SU(2) and point group projection Astrakhantsev et al. (2021)1
square 4x4 -0.7017449VQE + symm. circuit (64 pars., exact grad... run script, no paper cited3
square 6x6, open -0.6035218DMRG (bond dimension = 2048) run script, no paper cited5
square 6x6 -0.67887(2)2D RNN wavefunction (best variational) Moss et al. (2025)9
square, 40 sites no recordsolved exactly1
square, 50 sites no recordsolved exactly1
square 8x8, open no recordsolved exactly1
square 8x8 no recordsolved exactly1
square 10x10, open -0.628656(9)2D tensorized RNN (symmetry + annealing) Hibat-Allah et al. (2022)16
square 10x10 -0.67155260(3)CNN + MinSR Chen & Heyl (2023)12
square 12x12, open no recordsolved exactly1
square 12x12 no recordsolved exactly1
square 14x14, open no recordsolved exactly1
square 14x14 -0.668346(8)VMC with fermions (flux+neel+Jastrow) run script, no paper cited5
square 16x16, open -0.643504(3)2D minGRU (3 layers, c4v symmetry, parallel scan) Merali et al. (2026)4
square 16x16 no recordsolved exactly1
square 18x18, open no recordsolved exactly1
square 18x18 no recordsolved exactly1
square 20x20, open no recordsolved exactly1
square 20x20 no recordsolved exactly1
square 22x22, open no recordsolved exactly1
square 22x22 no recordsolved exactly1
square 24x24, open no recordsolved exactly1
square 24x24 no recordsolved exactly1
square 26x26, open no recordsolved exactly1
square 26x26 no recordsolved exactly1
square 28x28, open no recordsolved exactly1
square 28x28 no recordsolved exactly1
square 30x30 no recordsolved exactly1
square 32x32, open no recordsolved exactly1
square 32x32 no recordsolved exactly1
square 36x36 no recordsolved exactly1
square 40x40 no recordsolved exactly1
square 44x44 no recordsolved exactly1
square 48x48, open no recordsolved exactly1
square 48x48 no recordsolved exactly1
square 52x52 no recordsolved exactly1
square 56x56 no recordsolved exactly1
square 60x60 no recordsolved exactly1
square 64x64, open no recordsolved exactly1
square 64x64 no recordsolved exactly1
square 72x72 no recordsolved exactly1
square 80x80 no recordsolved exactly1
square 88x88 no recordsolved exactly1
square 96x96, open no recordsolved exactly1
square 96x96 no recordsolved exactly1
square 128x128, open no recordsolved exactly1
triangular 4x4 -0.5347197DMRG (bond dimension = 256) run script, no paper cited5
triangular 6x6 -0.560313(3)Group CNN (deep, symmetry-projected) Roth et al. (2022)8
triangular, 48 sites no recordsolved exactly1
triangular 10x10, open -0.5147668DMRG (bond dimension = 4096) run script, no paper cited7
triangular, 108 sites -0.55315(3)GCNN (deep group-equivariant CNN) Roth et al. (2022)2
triangular 12x12, open -0.5150648DMRG (Bond dimension = 3000) run script, no paper cited5
triangular 12x12 -0.54624(2)VMC with Dirac+field+Jastrow run script, no paper cited4
triangular 14x14, open -0.5138(1)2D Gated RNN Hibat-Allah et al. (2022)5
triangular 16x16, open -0.51668(9)2D Gated RNN Hibat-Allah et al. (2022)4

J1-J2#

56 instances, 43 with a record, energies as E/N (S.S)

instancerecordmethodrows
rectangular 4x6, J2 = 0.5 -0.5225249DMRG (bond dimension = 4096) run script, no paper cited6
square 4x4, J2 = 0.05 -0.6805657VQE + symm. circuit (64 pars., exact grad... run script, no paper cited3
square 4x4, J2 = 0.1 -0.6597832VQE + symm. circuit (64 pars., exact grad... run script, no paper cited3
square 4x4, J2 = 0.15 -0.6395066VQE + symm. circuit (64 pars., exact grad... run script, no paper cited3
square 4x4, J2 = 0.2 -0.6198639VQE + symm. circuit (64 pars., exact grad... run script, no paper cited3
square 4x4, J2 = 0.25 -0.6009332VQE + symm. circuit (64 pars., exact grad... run script, no paper cited3
square 4x4, J2 = 0.3 -0.5829420VQE + symm. circuit (64 pars., exact grad... run script, no paper cited3
square 4x4, J2 = 0.35 -0.5662285VQE + symm. circuit (64 pars., exact grad... run script, no paper cited3
square 4x4, J2 = 0.4 -0.5511033VQE + symm. circuit (64 pars., exact grad... run script, no paper cited3
square 4x4, J2 = 0.45 -0.5382766VQE + symm. circuit (64 pars., exact grad... run script, no paper cited3
square 4x4, J2 = 0.5 -0.5286202DMRG (bond dimension = 256) run script, no paper cited6
square 4x4, J2 = 0.6 -0.5258158VQE + symm. circuit (64 pars., exact grad... run script, no paper cited3
square 4x4, J2 = 0.65 -0.5393444VQE + symm. circuit (64 pars., exact grad... run script, no paper cited3
square 4x4, J2 = 0.7 -0.5637643VQE + symm. circuit (64 pars., exact grad... run script, no paper cited3
square 4x4, J2 = 0.75 -0.5942152VQE + symm. circuit (64 pars., exact grad... run script, no paper cited3
square 4x4, J2 = 0.8 -0.6273137VQE + symm. circuit (64 pars., exact grad... run script, no paper cited3
square 4x4, J2 = 0.85 -0.6617069VQE + symm. circuit (64 pars., exact grad... run script, no paper cited3
square 4x4, J2 = 0.9 -0.6967967VQE + symm. circuit (64 pars., exact grad... run script, no paper cited3
square 4x4, J2 = 0.95 -0.7324804VQE + symm. circuit (64 pars., exact grad... run script, no paper cited3
square 4x4, J2 = 1 -0.7684501VQE + symm. circuit (64 pars., exact grad... run script, no paper cited3
square 6x6, J2 = 0.3 -0.5618876DMRG (bond dimension = 2048) run script, no paper cited4
square 6x6, J2 = 0.4 -0.529687(7)RBM wave function Chen et al. (2022)6
square 6x6, J2 = 0.5 -0.503800(1)RBM+PP with momentum (K=0), spin-parity (even S)... Nomura & Imada (2021)11
square 6x6, J2 = 0.6 -0.49318(5)RBM wave function + 2-step Lanczos recursion Chen et al. (2022)8
square 6x6, J2 = 0.7 -0.5299243DMRG (bond dimension = 2048) run script, no paper cited5
square 6x6, J2 = 0.8 -0.586411(9)RBM wave function Chen et al. (2022)6
square 6x6, J2 = 0.9 -0.6478705DMRG (bond dimension = 2048) run script, no paper cited4
square 6x6, J2 = 1 -0.71429(1)RBM wave function Chen et al. (2022)6
square, 40 sites, J2 = 0.1 no recordsolved exactly1
square, 40 sites, J2 = 0.2 no recordsolved exactly1
square, 40 sites, J2 = 0.3 no recordsolved exactly1
square, 40 sites, J2 = 0.4 no recordsolved exactly1
square, 40 sites, J2 = 0.5 no recordsolved exactly1
square, 40 sites, J2 = 0.55 no recordsolved exactly1
square, 40 sites, J2 = 0.6 no recordsolved exactly1
square, 40 sites, J2 = 0.65 no recordsolved exactly1
square, 40 sites, J2 = 0.7 no recordsolved exactly1
square, 40 sites, J2 = 0.8 no recordsolved exactly1
square, 40 sites, J2 = 0.9 no recordsolved exactly1
square, 40 sites, J2 = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 8x8, J2 = 0.5 -0.498963(2)RBM+PP with momentum (K=0), spin-parity (even S)... Nomura & Imada (2021)8
square 8x8, J2 = 0.55 -0.48835(8)ClebschTree Vieijra & Nys (2021)1
square 10x10, J2 = 0.3 -0.55485(1)VMC with fermions (flux+neel+Jastrow) run script, no paper cited4
square 10x10, J2 = 0.4 -0.52388(2)RBM wave function Chen et al. (2022)5
square 10x10, J2 = 0.5 -0.4976939(2)CNN-MPS (h,D,l)=(32,20,20), Marshall sign... Fan et al. (2026)15
square 10x10, J2 = 0.6 -0.4774611DMRG (bond dimension = 1024) run script, no paper cited5
square 10x10, J2 = 0.7 -0.51889(2)RBM wave function Chen et al. (2022)4
square 10x10, J2 = 0.8 -0.57404(2)RBM wave function Chen et al. (2022)5
square 10x10, J2 = 0.9 -0.6269664DMRG (bond dimension = 1024) run script, no paper cited3
square 10x10, J2 = 1 -0.69670(2)RBM wave function Chen et al. (2022)5
square 14x14, J2 = 0.5 -0.49443(1)VMC with projected BCS (Z2 spin liquid) run script, no paper cited4
square 16x16, J2 = 0.5 -0.4969140(5)CNN-MPS Fan et al. (2026)3
square 20x20, J2 = 0.5 -0.4967987(6)CNN-MPS (h,D,l)=(32,15,20) Fan et al. (2026)2
triangular, 48 sites, J2 = 0.125 no recordsolved exactly48
triangular, 108 sites, J2 = 0.125 -0.51268(9)GCNN + Lanczos step Roth et al. (2022)4
triangular 12x12, J2 = 0.125 -0.51218(9)GCNN + Lanczos step Roth et al. (2022)4

Hubbard#

137 instances, 75 with a record, energies as E/site

instancerecordmethodrows
chain, 14 sites, U = 1, n ≈ 0.5714 -0.9116293DMRG (MaxBondDim = 1550, Extrap Energy = -12.762823... run script, no paper cited2
chain, 14 sites, U = 1.66810054, n ≈ 0.5714 no recordsolved exactly2
chain, 14 sites, U = 2.15443469, n ≈ 0.5714 -0.8542284DMRG (MaxBondDim ~1500) run script, no paper cited2
chain, 14 sites, U = 2.7825594, n ≈ 0.5714 -0.8300032DMRG (MaxBondDim ~1500) run script, no paper cited2
chain, 14 sites, U = 3.59381366, n ≈ 0.5714 -0.8043230DMRG (MaxBondDim ~1500) run script, no paper cited2
chain, 14 sites, U = 4.64158882, n ≈ 0.5714 -0.7783541DMRG (MaxBondDim ~1500) run script, no paper cited2
chain, 14 sites, U = 7.74263683, n ≈ 0.5714 -0.7304717DMRG (MaxBondDim ~1500) run script, no paper cited2
chain, 14 sites, U = 10, n ≈ 0.5714 -0.7103637DMRG (MaxBondDim ~1500, Extrap Eng = -9.9450941 +/-... run script, no paper cited2
rectangular 14x16, U = 8, n = 0.875 -0.75830(4)VAFQMC stripe length=7 Sorella (2023)1
rectangular 4x16, U = 8, n = 0.875 -0.76623(1)ACE (16 conv layers) + full symmetry projection Gu et al. (2026)8
rectangular 4x16, periodic/open, U = 2, n = 0.8125 -1.2852656DMRG (MaxLinkDim = 6000, MaxTruncErr~1.0E-04) run script, no paper cited1
rectangular 4x16, periodic/open, U = 8, n = 0.8125 -0.8530000DMRG (MaxLinkDim = 4000, MaxTruncErr~5.0E-05) run script, no paper cited1
rectangular 4x16, periodic/open, U = 2, n = 0.875 -1.2611875DMRG (MaxLinkDim = 4000, MaxTruncErr~8.0E-05) run script, no paper cited1
rectangular 4x16, periodic/open, U = 8, n = 0.875 -0.7508328DMRG (MaxLinkDim = 10000, MaxTruncErr~2.0E-05... run script, no paper cited2
rectangular 4x16, periodic/open, U = 2, n = 0.9375 -1.2199062DMRG (MaxLinkDim = 4000, MaxTruncErr~1.2E-04) run script, no paper cited1
rectangular 4x16, periodic/open, U = 8, n = 0.9375 -0.6378750DMRG (MaxLinkDim = 4000, MaxTruncErr~1.5E-05) run script, no paper cited1
rectangular 4x16, periodic/open, U = 2, n = 1 -1.1710781DMRG (MaxLinkDim = 4000, MaxTruncErr~3.5E-05) run script, no paper cited1
rectangular 4x16, periodic/open, U = 8, n = 1 -0.5144219DMRG (MaxLinkDim = 4000, MaxTruncErr~4.7E-07) run script, no paper cited1
rectangular 4x8, U = 8, n = 0.875 -0.76690(1)HFPS (hidden-fermion Pfaffian state) Chen et al. (2025)3
rectangular 4x8, periodic/open, U = 8, n = 0.875 -0.7363906DMRG (MaxLinkDim = 12000, MaxTruncErr~6.6E-06... run script, no paper cited4
rectangular 6x48, U = 8, n ≈ 0.8333 -0.82075(3)VMC with stripe of wavelength 6 (+Jastrow and... run script, no paper cited4
rectangular 6x48, U = 8, n = 0.875 -0.74834(3)VMC with stripe of wavelength 8 (+Jastrow and... run script, no paper cited4
rectangular 6x48, U = 12, n = 0.875 -0.62556(3)VMC with stripe of wavelength 6 (+Jastrow and... run script, no paper cited4
rectangular 6x48, U = 8, n ≈ 0.9167 -0.67269(3)VMC with stripe of wavelength 8 (+Jastrow and... run script, no paper cited4
square 4x4, U = 2, n = 0.5 -1.1559648DMRG (MaxLinkDim ~ 3200) run script, no paper cited2
square 4x4, U = 3.5981, n = 0.5 -1.1060144DMRG (MaxBondDim ~3200) run script, no paper cited3
square 4x4, U = 4, n = 0.5 -1.0959310DMRG (MaxBondDim ~ 3200) run script, no paper cited2
square 4x4, U = 6, n = 0.5 -1.0562454DMRG (MaxBondDim ~ 3200) run script, no paper cited2
square 4x4, U = 7.74264, n = 0.5 -1.0318221DMRG (MaxBondDim ~3200) run script, no paper cited3
square 4x4, U = 8, n = 0.5 -1.0287892DMRG (MaxBondDim ~ 3200) run script, no paper cited2
square 4x4, U = 10, n = 0.5 -1.0089505DMRG (MaxBondDim = 3200) run script, no paper cited3
square 4x4, U = 2, n = 0.625 -1.3360594DMRG (MaxBondDim = 7000) run script, no paper cited2
square 4x4, U = 2.1544, n = 0.625 -1.3257670DMRG (MaxBondDim 7000) run script, no paper cited3
square 4x4, U = 3.5981, n = 0.625 -1.2431527(4)VMC Hidden Fermion Determinant State Ansatz... Moreno et al. (2022)3
square 4x4, U = 4, n = 0.625 -1.2238086DMRG (MaxBondDim = 7000) run script, no paper cited2
square 4x4, U = 6, n = 0.625 -1.1473978DMRG (MaxBondDim = 7000) run script, no paper cited2
square 4x4, U = 7.74264, n = 0.625 -1.1002331DMRG (MaxBondDim = 7000) run script, no paper cited3
square 4x4, U = 8, n = 0.625 -1.0943979DMRG (MaxBondDim = 7000) run script, no paper cited2
square 4x4, U = 10, n = 0.625 -1.0564725DMRG (MaxBondDim = 7000) run script, no paper cited3
square 4x4, U = 2, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 4x4, U = 4, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 4x4, U = 6, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 4x4, U = 8, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 4x4, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 2, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 4x4, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 4, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 4x4, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 6, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 4x4, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 8, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 6x6, U = 4, n ≈ 0.6667 no recordno variational row1
square 6x6, U = 2, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 6x6, U = 4, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 6x6, U = 6, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 6x6, U = 8, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 6x6, U = 4, n ≈ 1.3333 no recordno variational row1
square 6x6, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 2, n = 1 -1.2079(1)VMC Hidden Fermion Determinant State Ansatz... Moreno et al. (2022)3
square 6x6, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 4, n = 1 -0.87173(2)VMC Hidden Fermion Determinant State Ansatz... Moreno et al. (2022)2
square 6x6, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 6, n = 1 -0.66094(3)VMC Hidden Fermion Determinant State Ansatz... Moreno et al. (2022)2
square 6x6, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 8, n = 1 -0.52705(3)VMC Hidden Fermion Determinant State Ansatz... Moreno et al. (2022)2
square, 50 sites, U = 8, n = 0.84 -0.82328(3)VAFQMC Sorella (2023)1
square 8x8, U = 4, n = 0.4375 no recordno variational row1
square 8x8, U = 4, n = 0.6875 no recordno variational row1
square 8x8, U = -8, n ≈ 0.7813 no recordsolved exactly1
square 8x8, U = -4, n ≈ 0.7813 no recordsolved exactly1
square 8x8, U = 4, n ≈ 0.7813 -1.130375(5)mVMC with SU(2) and momentum projections (gamma... run script, no paper cited3
square 8x8, U = 8, n ≈ 0.7813 -0.91483(2)mVMC with SU(2) and momentum projections (gamma... run script, no paper cited3
square 8x8, U = -8, n = 0.875 no recordsolved exactly1
square 8x8, U = -4, n = 0.875 no recordsolved exactly1
square 8x8, U = 4, n = 0.875 -1.00580(3)VMC with uniform BCS pairing (+Jastrow and backflow) run script, no paper cited2
square 8x8, U = 8, n = 0.875 -0.7458(6)Jastrow-backflow (JBf), 8x8 torus Sharma et al. (2025)8
square 8x8, U = -8, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 8x8, U = -4, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 8x8, U = 2, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 8x8, U = 4, n = 1 -0.859156(8)mVMC with SU(2) and momentum projections (gamma... run script, no paper cited5
square 8x8, U = 6, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 8x8, U = 8, n = 1 -0.52459(1)mVMC with SU(2) and momentum projections (gamma... run script, no paper cited4
square 8x8, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 2, n = 1 -1.19003(9)VMC Hidden Fermion Determinant State Ansatz... Moreno et al. (2022)2
square 8x8, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 4, n = 1 -0.8622(2)VMC Hidden Fermion Determinant State Ansatz... Moreno et al. (2022)2
square 8x8, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 6, n = 1 -0.6574(2)VMC Hidden Fermion Determinant State Ansatz... Moreno et al. (2022)3
square 8x8, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 8, n = 1 -0.5245(2)VMC Hidden Fermion Determinant State Ansatz... Moreno et al. (2022)2
square 8x8, periodic/open, U = 8, n = 1 -0.49944(4)VAFQMC Sorella (2023)3
square 10x10, U = 4, n = 0.8 no recordno variational row1
square 10x10, U = 2, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 10x10, U = 4, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 10x10, U = 6, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 10x10, U = 8, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 10x10, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 2, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 10x10, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 4, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 10x10, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 6, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 10x10, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 8, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 12x12, U = 4, n ≈ 0.8056 no recordno variational row1
square 12x12, U = 2, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 12x12, U = 4, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 12x12, U = 6, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 12x12, U = 8, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 12x12, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 2, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 12x12, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 4, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 12x12, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 6, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 12x12, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 8, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 14x14, U = 2, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 14x14, U = 4, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 14x14, U = 6, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 14x14, U = 8, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 14x14, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 2, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 14x14, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 4, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 14x14, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 6, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 14x14, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 8, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 16x16, U = 8, n ≈ 0.8281 -0.83788(6)VAFQMC stripe length=8 Sorella (2023)1
square 16x16, U = 8, n ≈ 0.8438 -0.81198(6)VAFQMC stripe length=8 Sorella (2023)1
square 16x16, U = 8, n ≈ 0.8516 -0.79896(5)VAFQMC stripe length=8 Sorella (2023)1
square 16x16, U = 8, n ≈ 0.8594 -0.78530(6)VAFQMC stripe length=8 Sorella (2023)2
square 16x16, U = 8, n ≈ 0.8672 -0.77196(6)VAFQMC stripe length=8 Sorella (2023)1
square 16x16, U = -8, n = 0.875 no recordsolved exactly1
square 16x16, U = -4, n = 0.875 no recordsolved exactly1
square 16x16, U = 4, n = 0.875 -1.02916(2)VAFQMC stripe length=8 Sorella (2023)2
square 16x16, U = 6, n = 0.875 -0.86592(2)VAFQMC stripe length=8 Sorella (2023)2
square 16x16, U = 8, n = 0.875 -0.75865(3)VAFQMC stripe length 8 Sorella (2023)13
square 16x16, U = 8, n ≈ 0.8828 -0.74455(3)VAFQMC stripe length=8 Sorella (2023)1
square 16x16, U = 4, n ≈ 0.8906 -1.00849(2)VAFQMC stripe length=8 Sorella (2023)2
square 16x16, U = 6, n ≈ 0.8906 -0.84058(2)VAFQMC stripe length=8 Sorella (2023)2
square 16x16, U = 8, n ≈ 0.8906 -0.73038(5)VAFQMC stripe length=8 Sorella (2023)2
square 16x16, U = 8, n ≈ 0.8984 -0.71584(5)VAFQMC stripe length=8 Sorella (2023)1
square 16x16, U = 8, n ≈ 0.9063 -0.70135(3)VAFQMC stripe length=8 Sorella (2023)2
square 16x16, U = 8, n ≈ 0.9141 -0.68678(5)VAFQMC stripe length=8 Sorella (2023)1
square 16x16, U = 8, n ≈ 0.9219 -0.67215(5)VAFQMC stripe length=8 Sorella (2023)1
square 16x16, U = 8, n = 0.9375 -0.64053(5)VAFQMC stripe length=8 Sorella (2023)1
square 16x16, U = -8, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 16x16, U = -4, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 16x16, U = 2, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 16x16, U = 4, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 16x16, U = 6, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 16x16, U = 8, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 16x16, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 8, n ≈ 0.8359 -0.82333(3)VAFQMC stripe length 8 APBC along the stripe Sorella (2023)2
square 16x16, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 8, n ≈ 0.8359, t12 -0.79937(4)mVMC with SU(2) and momentum projections (gamma... run script, no paper cited1
square 16x16, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 8, n ≈ 0.8359, t12, UV1V2 1.25918(3)mVMC with SU(2) and momentum projections (gamma... run script, no paper cited1
square 16x16, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 2, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 16x16, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 4, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 16x16, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 6, n = 1 no recordsolved exactly1
square 16x16, periodic/antiperiodic, U = 8, n = 1 -0.52427(4)VAFQMC Sorella (2023)4

Spinless t-V#

14 instances, 14 with a record, energies as E/site

instancerecordmethodrows
chain, 32 sites, V = 1, n = 0.5 -0.4983390DMRG (maxbonddim = 573) run script, no paper cited4
chain, 32 sites, V = 2, n = 0.5 -0.3852719DMRG (maxbonddim = 200) run script, no paper cited3
chain, 32 sites, V = 4, n = 0.5 -0.2344426DMRG (maxbonddim = 200) run script, no paper cited3
square 4x4, V = 0.01, n = 0.3125 -0.7487521(6)VMC Determinant Slater-Jastrow (RBM) Ansatz Romero et al. (2024)3
square 4x4, V = 0.1, n = 0.3125 -0.7376632(3)VMC Determinant Slater-Backflow-Jastrow (RBM)... Romero et al. (2024)5
square 4x4, V = 1, n = 0.3125 -0.6400407DMRG (maxbonddim = 74) run script, no paper cited5
square 4x4, V = 10, n = 0.3125 -0.2532535DMRG (maxbonddim = 74) run script, no paper cited5
square 6x6, V = 0.01, n ≈ 0.3611 -0.7759280(1)VMC Determinant Slater-Jastrow (RBM) Ansatz with... Romero et al. (2024)3
square 6x6, V = 0.1, n ≈ 0.3611 -0.759460(1)VMC Determinant Slater-Jastrow (RBM) Ansatz with... Romero et al. (2024)4
square 6x6, V = 1, n ≈ 0.3611 -0.6132263DMRG (maxbonddim = 4096) run script, no paper cited4
square 6x6, V = 10, n ≈ 0.3611 -0.2201239DMRG (maxbonddim = 4096) run script, no paper cited4
square 8x8, V = 1, n = 0.5 -0.4590635DMRG (maxbonddim = 4096) run script, no paper cited2
square 8x8, V = 2, n = 0.5 -0.2911555DMRG (maxbonddim = 4096) run script, no paper cited2
square 8x8, V = 4, n = 0.5 -0.1601344DMRG (maxbonddim = 4096) run script, no paper cited2

Transverse-field Ising#

7 instances, 7 with a record, energies as E/N (Pauli)

instancerecordmethodrows
chain, 10 sites, open, h = 1 -1.2381490DMRG (bond dimension = 13) run script, no paper cited6
chain, 10 sites, h = 1 -1.2784906DMRG (bond dimension = 28) run script, no paper cited4
chain, 32 sites, h = 0.5 -1.0635444DMRG (bond dimension = 24) run script, no paper cited5
chain, 32 sites, h = 1 -1.2737510DMRG (bond dimension = 71) run script, no paper cited5
square 6x6, h = 3 -3.2009084DMRG (bond dimension = 1024) run script, no paper cited4
square 12x12, open, h = 3 -3.1739018(2)2D Recurrent Neural Network (2DRNN) Hibat-Allah et al. (2020)4
square 20x20, open, h = 3 -3.1819700DMRG on TPU (bond dimension = 32768) Ganahl et al. (2023)7

Impurity#

12 instances, 12 with a record, energies as E (total)

instancerecordmethodrows
SB-DMFT-MI-HF, size 9 -34.5805205DMRG (bond dimension 100) using fork tensor product... Bauernfeind et al. (2017)2
SB-DMFT-MT-AHF, size 9 -13.8893249DMRG (bond dimension 100) using fork tensor product... Bauernfeind et al. (2017)2
SB-DMFT-MT-HF, size 9 -23.3009472DMRG (bond dimension 100) using fork tensor product... Bauernfeind et al. (2017)2
SB-IMP, size 9 -10.4871285DMRG (bond dimension 100) using fork tensor product... Bauernfeind et al. (2017)2
TB-DMFT, size 9 -112.9042852DMRG (bond dimension 350) using fork tensor product... Bauernfeind et al. (2017)3
TB-DMFT, size 19 -224.3360713DMRG (bond dimension 350) using fork tensor product... Bauernfeind et al. (2017)3
TB-DMFT, size 119 -1307.5645417DMRG (bond dimension 350) using fork tensor product... Bauernfeind et al. (2017)3
TB-DMFT, size 309 -3378.6762368DMRG (bond dimension 350) using fork tensor product... Bauernfeind et al. (2017)3
TB-DMFT-SOC, size 9 -112.8717703DMRG (bond dimension 350) using fork tensor product... Bauernfeind et al. (2017)3
TB-DMFT-SOC, size 19 -219.7669110DMRG (bond dimension 350) using fork tensor product... Bauernfeind et al. (2017)3
TB-DMFT-SOC, size 119 -1305.3902308DMRG (bond dimension 350) using fork tensor product... Bauernfeind et al. (2017)3
TB-DMFT-SOC, size 309 -3351.7573592DMRG (bond dimension 350) using fork tensor product... Bauernfeind et al. (2017)3