{
  "model": "Heisenberg",
  "lattice": "kagome-12x12",
  "n_sites": 432,
  "boundary": "P",
  "params": {},
  "cluster": "rhombic torus of 12 x 12 three-site unit cells, edge vectors 12 a1 and 12 a2 (a1, a2 the triangular Bravais vectors, 60 degrees apart), the pattern of kagome-8x8_192_P and kagome-10x10_300_P. Defined by arXiv:1311.5038: 'square (i.e., 3×L×L) clusters with periodic boundaries' (Model section; Table I sizes 48, 108, 192, 432), and by arXiv:1203.3421 (same authors): 'clusters with 432 (i.e. 3× 12× 12)'. The spin Hamiltonian is periodic; the 'mixed periodic-antiperiodic boundary conditions' these papers state are those of the fermionic mean-field state before projection",
  "instance_id": "Heisenberg/kagome-12x12_432_P",
  "rows": [
    {
      "energy": -740.717568,
      "sigma": 0.001728,
      "energy_variance": null,
      "dof": 432,
      "einf": 0,
      "v_score": null,
      "method": "VMC",
      "ansatz": "Gutzwiller",
      "method_detail": "U(1) Dirac spin liquid",
      "method_as_published": "U(1) Dirac spin liquid, 0-LS (VMC)",
      "family": "classic VMC",
      "bound_type": "variational",
      "bound_type_reason": "variational ansatz at a stated size; energy is an upper bound (assigned during source reading)",
      "reference": "Iqbal, Poilblanc & Becca, Vanishing spin gap in a competing spin-liquid phase in the kagome Heisenberg antiferromagnet, Phys. Rev. B 89, 020407(R) (2014), doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.89.020407, arXiv:1311.5038",
      "peer_reviewed": true,
      "source": "sweep-allresults-2026-11-12",
      "provenance": "primary",
      "verified": {
        "checked_on": "2026-11-12",
        "method": "source text of arXiv:1311.5038 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-12)",
        "reported_as": "−0.428656(1)",
        "note": "Table I, row 432, column 0-LS (Gutzwiller-projected U(1) Dirac spin liquid); sources/1311.5038.txt line 70; version read: arXiv text (sources/1311.5038.txt, pypdf layout mode); journal version not read in this reading (it was read in the second reading of 2026-11-16) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). Plausibility: every value lies above the 192-site variational records (about -0.4359) and, for the Dirac state, within 1e-4 of its 192-site value (-0.4286749), as a gapless state's energy should.",
        "secondary_of": null,
        "second_read": {
          "checked_on": "2026-11-16",
          "scope": "value",
          "method": "PRB 89, 020407(R) (2014) publisher PDF (fetched 2026-11-16), pypdf layout + plain; cross-read with arXiv:1311.5038 (latest v2) cached text qmbl/sources/1311.5038.txt; Table I row 432 identical in both",
          "location": "Table I, row 432, column 0-LS (journal p. 2; arXiv line 70)",
          "reported_as": "−0.428656(1)",
          "conversion": "-0.428656 x 4 x 432 = -740.717568; sigma 0.0000010 x 1728 = 0.001728",
          "note": "Eq. (1) H = J Σ_<ij> S_i·S_j, spin-1/2 operators, 'All energies will be given in units of J'; 'square (i.e., 3×L×L) clusters with periodic boundaries', L = 12 for 432. 0-LS is the bare Gutzwiller-projected U(1) Dirac state (no variational parameter): variational. The 432-site row is new in this paper (arXiv:1209.1858 Table I stops at 192 sites; the 48/108/192 rows of this table reprint 1209.1858). Journal = arXiv. Bracket not defined. No duplicate on data/Heisenberg/kagome-12x12_432_P.json.",
          "source_entry": "RP2-heisenberg-tfising#40 (qmbl-verify 2026-11-16)"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "energy": -747.392832,
      "sigma": 0.001728,
      "energy_variance": null,
      "dof": 432,
      "einf": 0,
      "v_score": null,
      "method": "VMC",
      "ansatz": "Gutzwiller",
      "method_detail": "U(1) Dirac spin liquid, 1 Lanczos step",
      "method_as_published": "U(1) Dirac spin liquid, 1-LS (VMC)",
      "family": "classic VMC",
      "bound_type": "variational",
      "bound_type_reason": "variational ansatz at a stated size; energy is an upper bound (assigned during source reading)",
      "reference": "Iqbal, Poilblanc & Becca, Vanishing spin gap in a competing spin-liquid phase in the kagome Heisenberg antiferromagnet, Phys. Rev. B 89, 020407(R) (2014), doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.89.020407, arXiv:1311.5038",
      "peer_reviewed": true,
      "source": "sweep-allresults-2026-11-12",
      "provenance": "primary",
      "verified": {
        "checked_on": "2026-11-12",
        "method": "source text of arXiv:1311.5038 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-12)",
        "reported_as": "−0.432519(1)",
        "note": "Table I, row 432, column 1-LS (one Lanczos step on the Dirac state); sources/1311.5038.txt line 70; version read: arXiv text (sources/1311.5038.txt, pypdf layout mode); journal version not read in this reading (it was read in the second reading of 2026-11-16) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). Plausibility: every value lies above the 192-site variational records (about -0.4359) and, for the Dirac state, within 1e-4 of its 192-site value (-0.4286749), as a gapless state's energy should.",
        "secondary_of": null,
        "second_read": {
          "checked_on": "2026-11-16",
          "scope": "value",
          "method": "PRB 89, 020407(R) (2014) publisher PDF (fetched 2026-11-16), pypdf layout + plain; cross-read with arXiv:1311.5038 (latest v2) cached text qmbl/sources/1311.5038.txt; Table I row 432 identical in both",
          "location": "Table I, row 432, column 1-LS (journal p. 2; arXiv line 70)",
          "reported_as": "−0.432519(1)",
          "conversion": "-0.432519 x 4 x 432 = -747.392832; sigma 0.0000010 x 1728 = 0.001728",
          "note": "Eq. (1) H = J Σ_<ij> S_i·S_j, spin-1/2 operators, 'All energies will be given in units of J'; 'square (i.e., 3×L×L) clusters with periodic boundaries', L = 12 for 432. 1-LS is one Lanczos step on the Dirac state, a variational state (Eq. 4): variational. The 432-site row is new in this paper (arXiv:1209.1858 Table I stops at 192 sites; the 48/108/192 rows of this table reprint 1209.1858). Journal = arXiv. Bracket not defined. No duplicate on data/Heisenberg/kagome-12x12_432_P.json.",
          "source_entry": "RP2-heisenberg-tfising#41 (qmbl-verify 2026-11-16)"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "energy": -754.30656,
      "sigma": 0.06912,
      "energy_variance": null,
      "dof": 432,
      "einf": 0,
      "v_score": null,
      "method": "VMC",
      "ansatz": "Gutzwiller",
      "method_detail": "U(1) Dirac spin liquid; extrapolated: variance → 0 (two points, p = 0, 1)",
      "method_as_published": "Zero-variance extrapolation of VMC (0,1 Lanczos steps)",
      "family": "classic VMC",
      "bound_type": "extrapolated",
      "bound_type_reason": "zero-variance or bond-dimension extrapolation; not an upper bound (assigned during source reading)",
      "reference": "Iqbal, Poilblanc & Becca, Vanishing spin gap in a competing spin-liquid phase in the kagome Heisenberg antiferromagnet, Phys. Rev. B 89, 020407(R) (2014), doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.89.020407, arXiv:1311.5038",
      "peer_reviewed": true,
      "source": "sweep-allresults-2026-11-12",
      "provenance": "primary",
      "verified": {
        "checked_on": "2026-11-12",
        "method": "source text of arXiv:1311.5038 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-12)",
        "reported_as": "−0.43652(4)",
        "note": "Table I, row 432, column 'Ground state': zero-variance extrapolation, 'only two points have been used for the 432-site cluster' (Fig. 3 caption); sources/1311.5038.txt line 70; version read: arXiv text (sources/1311.5038.txt, pypdf layout mode); journal version not read in this reading (it was read in the second reading of 2026-11-16) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). Plausibility (1311.5038): the 0-LS and 1-LS energies lie above the best variational energy on 192 sites (-0.435949) and decrease with p, as variational energies must; the zero-variance value -0.43652(4) is an estimate, not a bound, and lies 2.2e-4 above the 192-site zero-variance estimate of the same table (-0.43674(3)).",
        "secondary_of": null
      },
      "corrections": [
        {
          "field": "verified.note",
          "reported_as": "−0.43652(4) (Table I, row 432, column 'Ground state', bold)",
          "location": "Table I row 432; Fig. 3 caption 'only two points have been used for the 432-site cluster'; main text p. 3 'For the larger cluster, i.e., 432 sites, we also considered a quadratic fit: We first obtained an estimate of the A and B coefficients by a size scaling of the smaller clusters and then verified that indeed, these values give an excellent fit'",
          "version_read": "PRB 89, 020407(R) (2014) publisher PDF (fetched 2026-11-16), pypdf layout + plain; cross-read with arXiv:1311.5038 (latest v2) cached text qmbl/sources/1311.5038.txt; Table I row 432 identical in both",
          "conversion": "-0.43652 x 4 x 432 = -754.30656; sigma 0.000040 x 1728 = 0.06912",
          "checked_on": "2026-11-16",
          "reason": "The energy, sigma, bound_type (extrapolated), method string and reference are confirmed in the journal version; only the shared plausibility sentence copied onto this row is false for it: -0.43652 lies BELOW the 192-site variational record -0.4359, and the row is not the Dirac state. The sentence was written for bare Dirac/Z2 energies and should not be applied to a zero-variance estimate.",
          "source_entry": "RP2-heisenberg-tfising#42 (qmbl-verify 2026-11-16)",
          "edit": [
            "Plausibility: every value lies above the 192-site variational records (about -0.4359) and, for the Dirac state, within 1e-4 of its 192-site value (-0.4286749), as a gapless state's energy should.",
            "Plausibility (1311.5038): the 0-LS and 1-LS energies lie above the best variational energy on 192 sites (-0.435949) and decrease with p, as variational energies must; the zero-variance value -0.43652(4) is an estimate, not a bound, and lies 2.2e-4 above the 192-site zero-variance estimate of the same table (-0.43674(3))."
          ],
          "from": "Table I, row 432, column 'Ground state': zero-variance extrapolation, 'only two points have been used for the 432-site cluster' (Fig. 3 caption); sources/1311.5038.txt line 70; version read: arXiv text (sources/1311.5038.txt, pypdf layout mode); journal version not read in this reading (it was read in the second reading of 2026-11-16) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). Plausibility: every value lies above the 192-site variational records (about -0.4359) and, for the Dirac state, within 1e-4 of its 192-site value (-0.4286749), as a gapless state's energy should.",
          "to": "Table I, row 432, column 'Ground state': zero-variance extrapolation, 'only two points have been used for the 432-site cluster' (Fig. 3 caption); sources/1311.5038.txt line 70; version read: arXiv text (sources/1311.5038.txt, pypdf layout mode); journal version not read in this reading (it was read in the second reading of 2026-11-16) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). Plausibility (1311.5038): the 0-LS and 1-LS energies lie above the best variational energy on 192 sites (-0.435949) and decrease with p, as variational energies must; the zero-variance value -0.43652(4) is an estimate, not a bound, and lies 2.2e-4 above the 192-site zero-variance estimate of the same table (-0.43674(3))."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "energy": -740.67264,
      "sigma": 0.03456,
      "energy_variance": null,
      "dof": 432,
      "einf": 0,
      "v_score": null,
      "method": "VMC",
      "ansatz": "Gutzwiller",
      "method_detail": "U(1) Dirac spin liquid, [0,π] flux, n.n. hopping",
      "method_as_published": "U(1) Dirac SL (NN)",
      "family": "classic VMC",
      "bound_type": "variational",
      "bound_type_reason": "variational ansatz at a stated size; energy is an upper bound (assigned during source reading)",
      "reference": "Ran, Hermele, Lee & Wen, Projected-wave-function study of the spin-1/2 Heisenberg model on the kagomé lattice, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117205 (2007), doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.98.117205, arXiv:cond-mat/0611414 (Table I, row SL-[0, π], column 12x12x3 lattice)",
      "peer_reviewed": true,
      "source": "sweep-allresults-2026-11-12",
      "provenance": "secondary",
      "verified": {
        "checked_on": "2026-11-12",
        "method": "source text of arXiv:1105.0341 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-12)",
        "reported_as": "−0.42863(2)",
        "note": "page 3, 'Its energy per site is E/J = −0.42863(2)' for the nearest-neighbour U(1) Dirac spin liquid on the 432-site cluster ('on a 432-site cluster with mixed periodic-antiperiodic boundary conditions', lines 125-126); sources/1105.0341.txt line 136; version read: arXiv text (sources/1105.0341.txt, pypdf layout mode); journal version not read in this reading (it was read in the second reading of 2026-11-16) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). Plausibility: every value lies above the 192-site variational records (about -0.4359) and, for the Dirac state, within 1e-4 of its 192-site value (-0.4286749), as a gapless state's energy should.",
        "secondary_of": "Iqbal, Becca & Poilblanc, Projected wave function study of Z2 spin liquids on the kagome lattice for the spin-1/2 quantum Heisenberg antiferromagnet, Phys. Rev. B 84, 020407(R) (2011), doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.84.020407, arXiv:1105.0341",
        "journal_read": {
          "checked_on": "2026-11-18",
          "scope": "value",
          "method": "published PDF, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117205 (2007), journals.aps.org/prl/pdf/10.1103/PhysRevLett.98.117205, opened in a browser on 2026-11-18 (a script fetch of the same URL returned 401 on 2026-11-16); PDF text layer read and kept as the reading's evidence; arXiv compared: cond-mat/0611414",
          "location": "Table I (p. 117205-2), row SL-[0, π], column '12 × 12 × 3 lattice'; repeated in Table II (p. 117205-3), row 'U(1)-Dirac spin liquid'",
          "reported_as": "−0.42863(2) (energy per site, units of J)",
          "conversion": "-0.42863 x 432 x 4 = -740.67264 (S.S to the stored Pauli convention) = stored; sigma 0.00002 x 1728 = 0.03456",
          "note": "Journal and arXiv identical in this cell, and in the 8 × 8 × 3 cell (−0.42866(2)). The same table prints SL-[0, 0] on 12 × 12 × 3 as −0.4121(1), the coarser value the note on the uniform RVB row cites. Ran et al. are the reference since the correction of 2026-11-16 (ruled 2026-11-16); the row stays secondary of PRB 84, 020407(R), where the value was read.",
          "source_entry": "RP2-heisenberg-tfising#43 journal read (qmbl-verify 2026-11-16)"
        }
      },
      "corrections": [
        {
          "field": "reference",
          "to": "Ran, Hermele, Lee & Wen, Projected-wave-function study of the spin-1/2 Heisenberg model on the kagomé lattice, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117205 (2007), doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.98.117205, arXiv:cond-mat/0611414 (Table I, row SL-[0, π], column 12x12x3 lattice)",
          "reported_as": "'Its energy per site is E/J = −0.42863(2)' (1105.0341 / PRB 84, 020407 p. 2); Ran et al. Table I: 'SL-[0, π]    -0.42866(2) -0.42863(2)' under '8x8x3 lattice 12x12x3 lattice'",
          "location": "PRB 84, 020407(R) p. 2 right column (journal plain text line 152); the paragraph closes with superscripts 18,19 = Ran, Hermele, Lee & Wen PRL 98, 117205 and Hermele et al. PRB 77, 224413; qmbl/sources/cond-mat-0611414.txt lines 99-101 and 157-158",
          "version_read": "PRB 84, 020407(R) (2011) publisher PDF (fetched 2026-11-16), pypdf layout + plain; cross-read with arXiv:1105.0341 (latest v3) cached text; identical numbers; Ran et al.: cached arXiv:cond-mat/0611414 text; PRL journal PDF not reachable on 2026-11-16 (publisher returned 401), Ran et al. read in arXiv:cond-mat/0611414",
          "conversion": "-0.42863 x 4 x 432 = -740.67264; sigma 0.000020 x 1728 = 0.03456 (unchanged)",
          "checked_on": "2026-11-16",
          "reason": "The same value with the same error bar on the same 432-site (12 x 12 x 3, mixed spinon boundary conditions) torus is printed four years earlier by Ran et al.; the same authors' later review arXiv:1203.3421 (New J. Phys. 14, 115031) Sec. 2.2 states 'On a 432-site cluster its energy per site is E/J1 = −0.428 63(2) ... [32]' with [32] = Ran Y, Hermele M, Lee P A and Wen X G 2007 Phys. Rev. Lett. 98 117205 (sources/1203.3421.txt lines 503-505, 726). The pass comment (frustrated_2026_11_12.mjs lines 94-97, 100) reads [32] as this paper; it is Ran et al. The row is secondary of Ran et al.; no Ran row exists on Heisenberg/kagome-12x12_432_P, so this is not a duplicate. Energy, sigma, cluster, bound_type are unchanged.",
          "source_entry": "RP2-heisenberg-tfising#43 (qmbl-verify 2026-11-16)",
          "from": "Iqbal, Becca & Poilblanc, Projected wave function study of Z2 spin liquids on the kagome lattice for the spin-1/2 quantum Heisenberg antiferromagnet, Phys. Rev. B 84, 020407(R) (2011), doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.84.020407, arXiv:1105.0341"
        },
        {
          "field": "provenance",
          "to": "secondary",
          "reported_as": "'Its energy per site is E/J = −0.42863(2)' (1105.0341 / PRB 84, 020407 p. 2); Ran et al. Table I: 'SL-[0, π]    -0.42866(2) -0.42863(2)' under '8x8x3 lattice 12x12x3 lattice'",
          "location": "PRB 84, 020407(R) p. 2 right column (journal plain text line 152); the paragraph closes with superscripts 18,19 = Ran, Hermele, Lee & Wen PRL 98, 117205 and Hermele et al. PRB 77, 224413; qmbl/sources/cond-mat-0611414.txt lines 99-101 and 157-158",
          "version_read": "PRB 84, 020407(R) (2011) publisher PDF (fetched 2026-11-16), pypdf layout + plain; cross-read with arXiv:1105.0341 (latest v3) cached text; identical numbers; Ran et al.: cached arXiv:cond-mat/0611414 text; PRL journal PDF not reachable on 2026-11-16 (publisher returned 401), Ran et al. read in arXiv:cond-mat/0611414",
          "conversion": "-0.42863 x 4 x 432 = -740.67264; sigma 0.000020 x 1728 = 0.03456 (unchanged)",
          "checked_on": "2026-11-16",
          "reason": "The same value with the same error bar on the same 432-site (12 x 12 x 3, mixed spinon boundary conditions) torus is printed four years earlier by Ran et al.; the same authors' later review arXiv:1203.3421 (New J. Phys. 14, 115031) Sec. 2.2 states 'On a 432-site cluster its energy per site is E/J1 = −0.428 63(2) ... [32]' with [32] = Ran Y, Hermele M, Lee P A and Wen X G 2007 Phys. Rev. Lett. 98 117205 (sources/1203.3421.txt lines 503-505, 726). The pass comment (frustrated_2026_11_12.mjs lines 94-97, 100) reads [32] as this paper; it is Ran et al. The row is secondary of Ran et al.; no Ran row exists on Heisenberg/kagome-12x12_432_P, so this is not a duplicate. Energy, sigma, cluster, bound_type are unchanged.",
          "source_entry": "RP2-heisenberg-tfising#43 (qmbl-verify 2026-11-16)",
          "from": "primary"
        },
        {
          "field": "verified.secondary_of",
          "from": null,
          "to": "Iqbal, Becca & Poilblanc, Projected wave function study of Z2 spin liquids on the kagome lattice for the spin-1/2 quantum Heisenberg antiferromagnet, Phys. Rev. B 84, 020407(R) (2011), doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.84.020407, arXiv:1105.0341",
          "checked_on": "2026-11-16",
          "reason": "The value is read in PRB 84, 020407(R) (arXiv:1105.0341), which repeats Ran et al.'s number (ruled 2026-11-16).",
          "source_entry": "RP2-heisenberg-tfising#43 (qmbl-verify 2026-11-16)"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "energy": -712.21248,
      "sigma": 0.01728,
      "energy_variance": null,
      "dof": 432,
      "einf": 0,
      "v_score": null,
      "method": "VMC",
      "ansatz": "RVB",
      "method_detail": "uniform RVB spin liquid, [0,0] flux, n.n. hopping",
      "method_as_published": "uniform RVB SL [0, 0] (NN)",
      "family": "classic VMC",
      "bound_type": "variational",
      "bound_type_reason": "variational ansatz at a stated size; energy is an upper bound (assigned during source reading)",
      "reference": "Iqbal, Becca & Poilblanc, Projected wave function study of Z2 spin liquids on the kagome lattice for the spin-1/2 quantum Heisenberg antiferromagnet, Phys. Rev. B 84, 020407(R) (2011), doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.84.020407, arXiv:1105.0341",
      "peer_reviewed": true,
      "source": "sweep-allresults-2026-11-12",
      "provenance": "primary",
      "verified": {
        "checked_on": "2026-11-12",
        "method": "source text of arXiv:1105.0341 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-12)",
        "reported_as": "−0.41216(1)",
        "note": "page 3, 'its energy per site is E/J = −0.41216(1)' for the nearest-neighbour uniform RVB state [0, 0] on the same 432-site cluster; the sentence cites refs. 18 and 19 (Ran, Hermele, Lee & Wen, PRL 98, 117205; Hermele et al., PRB 77, 224413); Ran et al. print this state on the same 12x12x3 cluster only as −0.4121(1), so the five-digit value is kept as this paper's (ruled 2026-11-16); arXiv:1203.3421 credits −0.41216(1) to Ran et al. (its Ref. [32]); sources/1105.0341.txt line 144; version read: arXiv text (sources/1105.0341.txt, pypdf layout mode); journal version not read in this reading (it was read in the second reading of 2026-11-16) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). Plausibility: every value lies above the 192-site variational records (about -0.4359) and, for the Dirac state, within 1e-4 of its 192-site value (-0.4286749), as a gapless state's energy should.",
        "secondary_of": null
      },
      "corrections": [
        {
          "field": "verified.note",
          "checked_on": "2026-11-16",
          "edit": [
            "arXiv:1203.3421 (New J. Phys. 14, 115031) quotes this value and the Dirac one for 432 sites as this paper's (its Ref. [32])",
            "the sentence cites refs. 18 and 19 (Ran, Hermele, Lee & Wen, PRL 98, 117205; Hermele et al., PRB 77, 224413); Ran et al. print this state on the same 12x12x3 cluster only as −0.4121(1), so the five-digit value is kept as this paper's (ruled 2026-11-16); arXiv:1203.3421 credits −0.41216(1) to Ran et al. (its Ref. [32])"
          ],
          "reason": "Journal PRB 84, 020407(R) and arXiv:1105.0341v3 print '−0.41216(1).18,19'; Ran et al. Table I prints SL-[0, 0] on 12x12x3 as -0.4121(1); Hermele et al. 2008 print no energy per site; arXiv:1203.3421 Sec. 2.2 attributes the value to its Ref. [32] = Ran et al.",
          "source_entry": "RP2-heisenberg-tfising#44 (qmbl-verify 2026-11-16)",
          "from": "page 3, 'its energy per site is E/J = −0.41216(1)' for the nearest-neighbour uniform RVB state [0, 0] on the same 432-site cluster; arXiv:1203.3421 (New J. Phys. 14, 115031) quotes this value and the Dirac one for 432 sites as this paper's (its Ref. [32]); sources/1105.0341.txt line 144; version read: arXiv text (sources/1105.0341.txt, pypdf layout mode); journal version not read in this reading (it was read in the second reading of 2026-11-16) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). Plausibility: every value lies above the 192-site variational records (about -0.4359) and, for the Dirac state, within 1e-4 of its 192-site value (-0.4286749), as a gapless state's energy should.",
          "to": "page 3, 'its energy per site is E/J = −0.41216(1)' for the nearest-neighbour uniform RVB state [0, 0] on the same 432-site cluster; the sentence cites refs. 18 and 19 (Ran, Hermele, Lee & Wen, PRL 98, 117205; Hermele et al., PRB 77, 224413); Ran et al. print this state on the same 12x12x3 cluster only as −0.4121(1), so the five-digit value is kept as this paper's (ruled 2026-11-16); arXiv:1203.3421 credits −0.41216(1) to Ran et al. (its Ref. [32]); sources/1105.0341.txt line 144; version read: arXiv text (sources/1105.0341.txt, pypdf layout mode); journal version not read in this reading (it was read in the second reading of 2026-11-16) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). Plausibility: every value lies above the 192-site variational records (about -0.4359) and, for the Dirac state, within 1e-4 of its 192-site value (-0.4286749), as a gapless state's energy should."
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "energy": -740.8132992,
      "sigma": 0.0005184,
      "energy_variance": null,
      "dof": 432,
      "einf": 0,
      "v_score": null,
      "method": "VMC",
      "ansatz": "Gutzwiller",
      "method_detail": "U(1) Dirac spin liquid, n.n.n. hopping",
      "method_as_published": "U(1) Dirac spin liquid with n.n.n. hopping (VMC)",
      "family": "classic VMC",
      "bound_type": "variational",
      "bound_type_reason": "variational ansatz at a stated size; energy is an upper bound (assigned during source reading)",
      "reference": "Iqbal, Poilblanc, Thomale & Becca, Persistence of the gapless spin liquid in the breathing kagome Heisenberg antiferromagnet, Phys. Rev. B 97, 115127 (2018), doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.97.115127, arXiv:1712.04579",
      "peer_reviewed": true,
      "source": "sweep-allresults-2026-11-12",
      "provenance": "primary",
      "verified": {
        "checked_on": "2026-11-12",
        "method": "source text of arXiv:1712.04579 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-12)",
        "reported_as": "−0.4287114(3)",
        "note": "Supplemental Material Table S1, row J▽/J∆ = 1.0 (isotropic kagome), column 432; sources/1712.04579.txt line 509; version read: arXiv text (sources/1712.04579.txt, pypdf layout mode); journal version not read in this reading (it was read in the second reading of 2026-11-16) | Eq. (1): H = J∆ sum_∆ S_i.S_j + J▽ sum_▽ S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators; at J▽/J∆ = 1.0 the nearest-neighbour kagome Heisenberg model; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). Plausibility: every value lies above the 192-site variational records (about -0.4359) and, for the Dirac state, within 1e-4 of its 192-site value (-0.4286749), as a gapless state's energy should.",
        "secondary_of": null,
        "second_read": {
          "checked_on": "2026-11-16",
          "scope": "value",
          "method": "PRB 97, 115127 (2018) publisher Supplemental Material PDF (journals.aps.org/prb/supplemental/10.1103/PhysRevB.97.115127/Supp_Mat.pdf, fetched 2026-11-16) and publisher main-text PDF, pypdf layout + plain mode; cross-read with arXiv:1712.04579 (latest version v2) cached text qmbl/sources/1712.04579.txt; journal and arXiv Tables S1/S2 agree digit for digit",
          "location": "Supplemental Material Table S1, row J▽/J∆ = 1.0, column 432 (journal SM p. 2; arXiv text line 509)",
          "reported_as": "−0.4287114(3)",
          "conversion": "-0.4287114 x 4 x 432 = -740.8132992; sigma 3.0e-7 x 1728 = 0.0005184",
          "note": "Eq. (1) H = J∆ Σ_∆ S_i·S_j + J▽ Σ_▽ S_i·S_j, S = 1/2 operators; at J▽/J∆ = 1.0 the nearest-neighbour kagome Heisenberg model; table prints 'variational ground-state energies per site E/J∆'; clusters 'T1 = La1 and T2 = La2 ... N = 3L^2', L = 12 for N = 432, the instance's rhombic torus; 'mixed boundary conditions, i.e., anti-periodic along a1 and periodic along a2' are those of the auxiliary fermionic Hamiltonian ('In order to have a nondegenerate ground state of the auxiliary Hamiltonian, we choose antiperiodic and periodic boundary conditions along a1 and a2', Sec. II A), the spin model is periodic. Pure VMC (no Lanczos step) of a Gutzwiller-projected state: variational. Next-nearest-neighbour hopping is a variational parameter of the auxiliary Hamiltonian, not a spin coupling. Bracket not defined in the paper (stored as printed). Journal SM = arXiv. No other row on the instance carries this number (duplicate check against data/Heisenberg/kagome-12x12_432_P.json).",
          "source_entry": "RP2-heisenberg-tfising#0 (qmbl-verify 2026-11-16)"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "energy": -740.8395648,
      "sigma": 0.0006912,
      "energy_variance": null,
      "dof": 432,
      "einf": 0,
      "v_score": null,
      "method": "VMC",
      "ansatz": "Gutzwiller",
      "method_detail": "gapped Z2[0,π]β* spin liquid",
      "method_as_published": "gapped Z2[0,π]β* spin liquid (VMC)",
      "family": "classic VMC",
      "bound_type": "variational",
      "bound_type_reason": "variational ansatz at a stated size; energy is an upper bound (assigned during source reading)",
      "reference": "Iqbal, Poilblanc, Thomale & Becca, Persistence of the gapless spin liquid in the breathing kagome Heisenberg antiferromagnet, Phys. Rev. B 97, 115127 (2018), doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.97.115127, arXiv:1712.04579",
      "peer_reviewed": true,
      "source": "sweep-allresults-2026-11-12",
      "provenance": "primary",
      "verified": {
        "checked_on": "2026-11-12",
        "method": "source text of arXiv:1712.04579 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-12)",
        "reported_as": "−0.4287266(4)",
        "note": "Supplemental Material Table S2, row J▽/J∆ = 1.0 (isotropic kagome), column 432; sources/1712.04579.txt line 530; version read: arXiv text (sources/1712.04579.txt, pypdf layout mode); journal version not read in this reading (it was read in the second reading of 2026-11-16) | Eq. (1): H = J∆ sum_∆ S_i.S_j + J▽ sum_▽ S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators; at J▽/J∆ = 1.0 the nearest-neighbour kagome Heisenberg model; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). Plausibility: every value lies above the 192-site variational records (about -0.4359) and, for the Dirac state, within 1e-4 of its 192-site value (-0.4286749), as a gapless state's energy should.",
        "secondary_of": null,
        "second_read": {
          "checked_on": "2026-11-16",
          "scope": "value",
          "method": "PRB 97, 115127 (2018) publisher Supplemental Material PDF (journals.aps.org/prb/supplemental/10.1103/PhysRevB.97.115127/Supp_Mat.pdf, fetched 2026-11-16) and publisher main-text PDF, pypdf layout + plain mode; cross-read with arXiv:1712.04579 (latest version v2) cached text qmbl/sources/1712.04579.txt; journal and arXiv Tables S1/S2 agree digit for digit",
          "location": "Supplemental Material Table S2, row J▽/J∆ = 1.0, column 432 (journal SM p. 2; arXiv text line 530)",
          "reported_as": "−0.4287266(4)",
          "conversion": "-0.4287266 x 4 x 432 = -740.8395648; sigma 4.0e-7 x 1728 = 0.0006912",
          "note": "Eq. (1) H = J∆ Σ_∆ S_i·S_j + J▽ Σ_▽ S_i·S_j, S = 1/2 operators; at J▽/J∆ = 1.0 the nearest-neighbour kagome Heisenberg model; table prints 'variational ground-state energies per site E/J∆'; clusters 'T1 = La1 and T2 = La2 ... N = 3L^2', L = 12 for N = 432, the instance's rhombic torus; 'mixed boundary conditions, i.e., anti-periodic along a1 and periodic along a2' are those of the auxiliary fermionic Hamiltonian ('In order to have a nondegenerate ground state of the auxiliary Hamiltonian, we choose antiperiodic and periodic boundary conditions along a1 and a2', Sec. II A), the spin model is periodic. Pure VMC (no Lanczos step) of a Gutzwiller-projected state: variational. Next-nearest-neighbour hopping is a variational parameter of the auxiliary Hamiltonian, not a spin coupling. Bracket not defined in the paper (stored as printed). Journal SM = arXiv. No other row on the instance carries this number (duplicate check against data/Heisenberg/kagome-12x12_432_P.json).",
          "source_entry": "RP2-heisenberg-tfising#1 (qmbl-verify 2026-11-16)"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "energy": -692.928,
      "sigma": 0.1728,
      "energy_variance": null,
      "dof": 432,
      "einf": 0,
      "v_score": null,
      "method": "VMC",
      "ansatz": "Gutzwiller",
      "method_detail": "U(1) spin liquid, [π/2,0] flux, mixed spinon boundaries",
      "method_as_published": "VMC, Gutzwiller-projected SL-[π/2, 0] spin liquid, mixed spinon boundary conditions",
      "family": "classic VMC",
      "bound_type": "variational",
      "bound_type_reason": "variational ansatz at a stated size; energy is an upper bound (assigned during source reading)",
      "reference": "Ran, Hermele, Lee & Wen, Projected-Wave-Function Study of the Spin-1/2 Heisenberg Model on the Kagomé Lattice, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117205 (2007), doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.98.117205, arXiv:cond-mat/0611414",
      "peer_reviewed": true,
      "source": "sweep-allresults-2026-11-18",
      "provenance": "primary",
      "verified": {
        "checked_on": "2026-11-18",
        "method": "source text of arXiv:cond-mat/0611414 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-18)",
        "reported_as": "−0.4010(1)",
        "note": "Table I, row SL-[π/2, 0], column 12x12x3 lattice ('For all candidate projected spin-liquids, we list the energy per site in unit of J'); sources/cond-mat-0611414.txt line 93; version read: Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117205 publisher PDF (2026-11-18, Tables I and III identical to the arXiv text) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). The spin Hamiltonian is periodic; the mixed periodic-antiperiodic boundary conditions are those of the fermionic mean-field state before projection. Plausibility: every value lies above the instance's best variational energy, -0.432519 per site (1-LS VMC, arXiv:1311.5038).",
        "secondary_of": null
      }
    },
    {
      "energy": -675.648,
      "sigma": 0.1728,
      "energy_variance": null,
      "dof": 432,
      "einf": 0,
      "v_score": null,
      "method": "VMC",
      "ansatz": "Gutzwiller",
      "method_detail": "U(1) spin liquid, [±π/2,0] flux, mixed spinon boundaries",
      "method_as_published": "VMC, Gutzwiller-projected SL-[±π/2, 0] spin liquid, mixed spinon boundary conditions",
      "family": "classic VMC",
      "bound_type": "variational",
      "bound_type_reason": "variational ansatz at a stated size; energy is an upper bound (assigned during source reading)",
      "reference": "Ran, Hermele, Lee & Wen, Projected-Wave-Function Study of the Spin-1/2 Heisenberg Model on the Kagomé Lattice, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117205 (2007), doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.98.117205, arXiv:cond-mat/0611414",
      "peer_reviewed": true,
      "source": "sweep-allresults-2026-11-18",
      "provenance": "primary",
      "verified": {
        "checked_on": "2026-11-18",
        "method": "source text of arXiv:cond-mat/0611414 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-18)",
        "reported_as": "−0.3910(1)",
        "note": "Table I, row SL-[±π/2, 0], column 12x12x3 lattice ('For all candidate projected spin-liquids, we list the energy per site in unit of J'); sources/cond-mat-0611414.txt line 95; version read: Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117205 publisher PDF (2026-11-18, Tables I and III identical to the arXiv text) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). The spin Hamiltonian is periodic; the mixed periodic-antiperiodic boundary conditions are those of the fermionic mean-field state before projection. Plausibility: every value lies above the instance's best variational energy, -0.432519 per site (1-LS VMC, arXiv:1311.5038).",
        "secondary_of": null
      }
    },
    {
      "energy": -660.4416,
      "sigma": 0.1728,
      "energy_variance": null,
      "dof": 432,
      "einf": 0,
      "v_score": null,
      "method": "VMC",
      "ansatz": "Gutzwiller",
      "method_detail": "U(1) spin liquid, [π/2,π] flux, mixed spinon boundaries",
      "method_as_published": "VMC, Gutzwiller-projected SL-[π/2, π] spin liquid, mixed spinon boundary conditions",
      "family": "classic VMC",
      "bound_type": "variational",
      "bound_type_reason": "variational ansatz at a stated size; energy is an upper bound (assigned during source reading)",
      "reference": "Ran, Hermele, Lee & Wen, Projected-Wave-Function Study of the Spin-1/2 Heisenberg Model on the Kagomé Lattice, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117205 (2007), doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.98.117205, arXiv:cond-mat/0611414",
      "peer_reviewed": true,
      "source": "sweep-allresults-2026-11-18",
      "provenance": "primary",
      "verified": {
        "checked_on": "2026-11-18",
        "method": "source text of arXiv:cond-mat/0611414 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-18)",
        "reported_as": "−0.3822(1)",
        "note": "Table I, row SL-[π/2, π], column 12x12x3 lattice ('For all candidate projected spin-liquids, we list the energy per site in unit of J'); sources/cond-mat-0611414.txt line 97; version read: Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117205 publisher PDF (2026-11-18, Tables I and III identical to the arXiv text) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). The spin Hamiltonian is periodic; the mixed periodic-antiperiodic boundary conditions are those of the fermionic mean-field state before projection. Plausibility: every value lies above the instance's best variational energy, -0.432519 per site (1-LS VMC, arXiv:1311.5038).",
        "secondary_of": null
      }
    },
    {
      "energy": -712.1088,
      "sigma": 0.1728,
      "energy_variance": null,
      "dof": 432,
      "einf": 0,
      "v_score": null,
      "method": "VMC",
      "ansatz": "RVB",
      "method_detail": "uniform RVB spin liquid, [0,0] flux, mixed spinon boundaries",
      "method_as_published": "VMC, Gutzwiller-projected uniform RVB SL-[0, 0] spin liquid, mixed spinon boundary conditions",
      "family": "classic VMC",
      "bound_type": "variational",
      "bound_type_reason": "variational ansatz at a stated size; energy is an upper bound (assigned during source reading)",
      "reference": "Ran, Hermele, Lee & Wen, Projected-Wave-Function Study of the Spin-1/2 Heisenberg Model on the Kagomé Lattice, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117205 (2007), doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.98.117205, arXiv:cond-mat/0611414",
      "peer_reviewed": true,
      "source": "sweep-allresults-2026-11-18",
      "provenance": "primary",
      "verified": {
        "checked_on": "2026-11-18",
        "method": "source text of arXiv:cond-mat/0611414 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-18)",
        "reported_as": "−0.4121(1)",
        "note": "Table I, row uniform RVB SL-[0, 0], column 12x12x3 lattice ('For all candidate projected spin-liquids, we list the energy per site in unit of J'); sources/cond-mat-0611414.txt line 99; version read: Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117205 publisher PDF (2026-11-18, Tables I and III identical to the arXiv text) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). The spin Hamiltonian is periodic; the mixed periodic-antiperiodic boundary conditions are those of the fermionic mean-field state before projection. Plausibility: every value lies above the instance's best variational energy, -0.432519 per site (1-LS VMC, arXiv:1311.5038).",
        "secondary_of": null
      }
    },
    {
      "energy": -740.34432,
      "sigma": 0.03456,
      "energy_variance": null,
      "dof": 432,
      "einf": 0,
      "v_score": null,
      "method": "VMC",
      "ansatz": "Gutzwiller",
      "method_detail": "VBS state next to the U(1) Dirac spin liquid, |χ1/χ2| = 1.05, mixed spinon boundaries",
      "method_as_published": "VMC, Gutzwiller-projected VBS state (|χ1/χ2| = 1.05), mixed spinon boundary conditions",
      "family": "classic VMC",
      "bound_type": "variational",
      "bound_type_reason": "variational ansatz at a stated size; energy is an upper bound (assigned during source reading)",
      "reference": "Ran, Hermele, Lee & Wen, Projected-Wave-Function Study of the Spin-1/2 Heisenberg Model on the Kagomé Lattice, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117205 (2007), doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.98.117205, arXiv:cond-mat/0611414",
      "peer_reviewed": true,
      "source": "sweep-allresults-2026-11-18",
      "provenance": "primary",
      "verified": {
        "checked_on": "2026-11-18",
        "method": "source text of arXiv:cond-mat/0611414 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-18)",
        "reported_as": "−0.42844(2)",
        "note": "Table III, row 'VBS state (|χ1/χ2| = 1.05)', column 12x12x3 lattice ('energy per site in unit of J for possible' instabilities of the U(1)-Dirac state); sources/cond-mat-0611414.txt line 159; version read: Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117205 publisher PDF (2026-11-18, Tables I and III identical to the arXiv text) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). The spin Hamiltonian is periodic; the mixed periodic-antiperiodic boundary conditions are those of the fermionic mean-field state before projection. Plausibility: every value lies above the instance's best variational energy, -0.432519 per site (1-LS VMC, arXiv:1311.5038).",
        "secondary_of": null
      }
    },
    {
      "energy": -740.37888,
      "sigma": 0.03456,
      "energy_variance": null,
      "dof": 432,
      "einf": 0,
      "v_score": null,
      "method": "VMC",
      "ansatz": "Gutzwiller",
      "method_detail": "VBS state next to the U(1) Dirac spin liquid, |χ1/χ2| = 0.95, mixed spinon boundaries",
      "method_as_published": "VMC, Gutzwiller-projected VBS state (|χ1/χ2| = 0.95), mixed spinon boundary conditions",
      "family": "classic VMC",
      "bound_type": "variational",
      "bound_type_reason": "variational ansatz at a stated size; energy is an upper bound (assigned during source reading)",
      "reference": "Ran, Hermele, Lee & Wen, Projected-Wave-Function Study of the Spin-1/2 Heisenberg Model on the Kagomé Lattice, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117205 (2007), doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.98.117205, arXiv:cond-mat/0611414",
      "peer_reviewed": true,
      "source": "sweep-allresults-2026-11-18",
      "provenance": "primary",
      "verified": {
        "checked_on": "2026-11-18",
        "method": "source text of arXiv:cond-mat/0611414 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-18)",
        "reported_as": "−0.42846(2)",
        "note": "Table III, row 'VBS state (|χ1/χ2| = 0.95)', column 12x12x3 lattice ('energy per site in unit of J for possible' instabilities of the U(1)-Dirac state); sources/cond-mat-0611414.txt line 161; version read: Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117205 publisher PDF (2026-11-18, Tables I and III identical to the arXiv text) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). The spin Hamiltonian is periodic; the mixed periodic-antiperiodic boundary conditions are those of the fermionic mean-field state before projection. Plausibility: every value lies above the instance's best variational energy, -0.432519 per site (1-LS VMC, arXiv:1311.5038).",
        "secondary_of": null
      }
    },
    {
      "energy": -740.49984,
      "sigma": 0.03456,
      "energy_variance": null,
      "dof": 432,
      "einf": 0,
      "v_score": null,
      "method": "VMC",
      "ansatz": "Gutzwiller",
      "method_detail": "chiral spin liquid, θ = 0.05 flux through the triangles, mixed spinon boundaries",
      "method_as_published": "VMC, Gutzwiller-projected chiral spin liquid (θ = 0.05), mixed spinon boundary conditions",
      "family": "classic VMC",
      "bound_type": "variational",
      "bound_type_reason": "variational ansatz at a stated size; energy is an upper bound (assigned during source reading)",
      "reference": "Ran, Hermele, Lee & Wen, Projected-Wave-Function Study of the Spin-1/2 Heisenberg Model on the Kagomé Lattice, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117205 (2007), doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.98.117205, arXiv:cond-mat/0611414",
      "peer_reviewed": true,
      "source": "sweep-allresults-2026-11-18",
      "provenance": "primary",
      "verified": {
        "checked_on": "2026-11-18",
        "method": "source text of arXiv:cond-mat/0611414 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-18)",
        "reported_as": "−0.42853(2)",
        "note": "Table III, row 'chiral spin liquid (θ = 0.05)', column 12x12x3 lattice ('energy per site in unit of J for possible' instabilities of the U(1)-Dirac state); sources/cond-mat-0611414.txt line 163; version read: Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117205 publisher PDF (2026-11-18, Tables I and III identical to the arXiv text) | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). The spin Hamiltonian is periodic; the mixed periodic-antiperiodic boundary conditions are those of the fermionic mean-field state before projection. Plausibility: every value lies above the instance's best variational energy, -0.432519 per site (1-LS VMC, arXiv:1311.5038).",
        "secondary_of": null
      }
    },
    {
      "energy": -740.82816,
      "sigma": 0.01728,
      "energy_variance": null,
      "dof": 432,
      "einf": 0,
      "v_score": null,
      "method": "VMC",
      "ansatz": "Gutzwiller",
      "method_detail": "U(1) Dirac spin liquid, [0,π;0,π] flux, n.n.n. hopping",
      "method_as_published": "VMC, extended U(1) Dirac SL [0, π; 0, π] (optimised 2nd-neighbour hopping)",
      "family": "classic VMC",
      "bound_type": "variational",
      "bound_type_reason": "variational ansatz at a stated size; energy is an upper bound (assigned during source reading)",
      "reference": "Iqbal, Becca & Poilblanc, Projected wave function study of Z2 spin liquids on the kagome lattice for the spin-1/2 quantum Heisenberg antiferromagnet, Phys. Rev. B 84, 020407(R) (2011), doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.84.020407, arXiv:1105.0341",
      "peer_reviewed": true,
      "source": "sweep-allresults-2026-11-18",
      "provenance": "primary",
      "verified": {
        "checked_on": "2026-11-18",
        "method": "source text of arXiv:1105.0341 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-18)",
        "reported_as": "−0.42872(1)",
        "note": "page 3, 'For the present cluster, these values are E/J = −0.42872(1) per site, and χ2 = −0.0186(2)' (the [0,π; 0,π] state, nearest-neighbour Hamiltonian); the same value is printed for the 576-site cluster in arXiv:1011.3954, a row there; sources/1105.0341.txt line 182; version read: Phys. Rev. B 84, 020407(R) publisher PDF (2026-11-16) and its Supplemental Material (2026-11-18), values identical to the arXiv text | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). The spin Hamiltonian is periodic; the mixed periodic-antiperiodic boundary conditions are those of the fermionic mean-field state before projection. Plausibility: every value lies above the instance's best variational energy, -0.432519 per site (1-LS VMC, arXiv:1311.5038).",
        "secondary_of": null
      }
    },
    {
      "energy": -712.41984,
      "sigma": 0.01728,
      "energy_variance": null,
      "dof": 432,
      "einf": 0,
      "v_score": null,
      "method": "VMC",
      "ansatz": "RVB",
      "method_detail": "uniform RVB spin liquid, [0,0;π,π] flux, n.n.n. hopping",
      "method_as_published": "VMC, extended uniform RVB SL [0, 0; π, π] (optimised 2nd-neighbour hopping)",
      "family": "classic VMC",
      "bound_type": "variational",
      "bound_type_reason": "variational ansatz at a stated size; energy is an upper bound (assigned during source reading)",
      "reference": "Iqbal, Becca & Poilblanc, Projected wave function study of Z2 spin liquids on the kagome lattice for the spin-1/2 quantum Heisenberg antiferromagnet, Phys. Rev. B 84, 020407(R) (2011), doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.84.020407, arXiv:1105.0341",
      "peer_reviewed": true,
      "source": "sweep-allresults-2026-11-18",
      "provenance": "primary",
      "verified": {
        "checked_on": "2026-11-18",
        "method": "source text of arXiv:1105.0341 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-18)",
        "reported_as": "−0.41228(1)",
        "note": "Supplemental Material p. 1, 'The energies of the NN [0, 0] SL and the extended 2nd and 3rd n.n. [0, 0] SLs ... are E/J = −0.41216(1), E/J = −0.41228(1), E/J = −0.412308(1) respectively' (the 2nd-neighbour state is the [0, 0;π,π] state of the main text, page 4); journal Supplemental Material (Supp-material.pdf and .tex, APS) prints the same sentence; sources/1105.0341.txt line 318; version read: Phys. Rev. B 84, 020407(R) publisher PDF (2026-11-16) and its Supplemental Material (2026-11-18), values identical to the arXiv text | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). The spin Hamiltonian is periodic; the mixed periodic-antiperiodic boundary conditions are those of the fermionic mean-field state before projection. Plausibility: every value lies above the instance's best variational energy, -0.432519 per site (1-LS VMC, arXiv:1311.5038).",
        "secondary_of": null
      }
    },
    {
      "energy": -712.468224,
      "sigma": 0.001728,
      "energy_variance": null,
      "dof": 432,
      "einf": 0,
      "v_score": null,
      "method": "VMC",
      "ansatz": "RVB",
      "method_detail": "uniform RVB spin liquid, [0,0] flux, hopping to 3rd neighbours",
      "method_as_published": "VMC, extended uniform RVB SL [0, 0] (optimised hopping to 3rd neighbours)",
      "family": "classic VMC",
      "bound_type": "variational",
      "bound_type_reason": "variational ansatz at a stated size; energy is an upper bound (assigned during source reading)",
      "reference": "Iqbal, Becca & Poilblanc, Projected wave function study of Z2 spin liquids on the kagome lattice for the spin-1/2 quantum Heisenberg antiferromagnet, Phys. Rev. B 84, 020407(R) (2011), doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.84.020407, arXiv:1105.0341",
      "peer_reviewed": true,
      "source": "sweep-allresults-2026-11-18",
      "provenance": "primary",
      "verified": {
        "checked_on": "2026-11-18",
        "method": "source text of arXiv:1105.0341 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-18)",
        "reported_as": "−0.412308(1)",
        "note": "Supplemental Material p. 1, same sentence, the extended 3rd n.n. [0, 0] SL (the main text, page 4: 'the 3rd NN uniform RVB SL with optimized χ2 and χ′3s'); journal Supplemental Material prints the same sentence; sources/1105.0341.txt line 318; version read: Phys. Rev. B 84, 020407(R) publisher PDF (2026-11-16) and its Supplemental Material (2026-11-18), values identical to the arXiv text | H = J sum_<ij> S_i.S_j with spin-1/2 operators, nearest neighbours only; energies printed as E/J per site, the S.S convention per site (RULES.md 5). The spin Hamiltonian is periodic; the mixed periodic-antiperiodic boundary conditions are those of the fermionic mean-field state before projection. Plausibility: every value lies above the instance's best variational energy, -0.432519 per site (1-LS VMC, arXiv:1311.5038).",
        "secondary_of": null
      }
    }
  ],
  "url": "https://qmbl.org/i/Heisenberg/kagome-12x12_432_P/",
  "per_site_divisor": 1728,
  "per_site_label": "E/N (S.S)",
  "best": {
    "exact": null,
    "variational": {
      "energy": -747.392832,
      "sigma": 0.001728,
      "method": "VMC",
      "ansatz": "Gutzwiller",
      "method_detail": "U(1) Dirac spin liquid, 1 Lanczos step",
      "reference": "Iqbal, Poilblanc & Becca, Vanishing spin gap in a competing spin-liquid phase in the kagome Heisenberg antiferromagnet, Phys. Rev. B 89, 020407(R) (2014), doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.89.020407, arXiv:1311.5038",
      "bound_type": "variational",
      "energy_per_site": -0.432519
    },
    "projected": null,
    "extrapolated": {
      "energy": -754.30656,
      "sigma": 0.06912,
      "method": "VMC",
      "ansatz": "Gutzwiller",
      "method_detail": "U(1) Dirac spin liquid; extrapolated: variance → 0 (two points, p = 0, 1)",
      "reference": "Iqbal, Poilblanc & Becca, Vanishing spin gap in a competing spin-liquid phase in the kagome Heisenberg antiferromagnet, Phys. Rev. B 89, 020407(R) (2014), doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.89.020407, arXiv:1311.5038",
      "bound_type": "extrapolated",
      "energy_per_site": -0.43652
    },
    "approximate": null,
    "below_exact": []
  },
  "no_best_reason": null,
  "record": {
    "energy": -754.30656,
    "sigma": 0.06912,
    "method": "VMC",
    "ansatz": "Gutzwiller",
    "method_detail": "U(1) Dirac spin liquid; extrapolated: variance → 0 (two points, p = 0, 1)",
    "reference": "Iqbal, Poilblanc & Becca, Vanishing spin gap in a competing spin-liquid phase in the kagome Heisenberg antiferromagnet, Phys. Rev. B 89, 020407(R) (2014), doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.89.020407, arXiv:1311.5038",
    "bound_type": "extrapolated",
    "energy_per_site": -0.43652
  },
  "no_record_reason": null
}
