QMBLthe quantum many-body leaderboard

All instances / Hubbard

Hubbard rectangular 12x16, open, U = 8, n = 0.875

QMBL lists 19 published ground-state energies for the Hubbard model (rectangular 12x16, open, U = 8, n = 0.875). The best variational energy is -0.72212, by VMC (transformer BF) in Gu et al. (2026). QMBL has no exact energy for this instance. Energies as E/site.

Best values (rules §6)

best variational -0.72212 VMC (transformer BF)
Gu et al. (2026) · the lowest unflagged variational energy, a strict variational bound

Energies as E/site. Classes are different claims and are not ranked against each other.

The Hamiltonian

H = −t ∑⟨ij⟩,σ (c†iσcjσ + h.c.) + U ∑i ni↑ni↓

t = 1, U = 8, N↑ = N↓ = 84 on 192 sites.

lattice
rectangular-12x16
sites
192
boundary
open
Nf
84
U
8
energies
19

Stored as a total energy; quoted here as E/site, which is what the papers report (how the conversion works).

Every published energy

Grouped by what the number is. The exact energy comes first where there is one; in every other group the lowest unflagged energy is its best value, and each row's distance is to that best (rules §6).

Strict variational upper bounds (19)

Energies that a variational state reached (VMC, DMRG and MPS at finite bond dimension, PEPS, NQS, VQE). Each is an upper bound on the ground-state energy.

E/sitedistance to class bestσVar(E)V-score methodsourcecodeyearcomment
-0.72212best variational 0 n/a n/a n/a VMC (transformer BF)
peer reviewed
Gu et al. (2026) 2026
-0.7202 1.9e-3 2.3e-4 n/a n/a simple update (fPEPS)
peer reviewed
Liu et al. (2025) 2025
-0.7201 2.0e-3 3.3e-4 n/a n/a simple update (fPEPS)
peer reviewed
Liu et al. (2025) 2025
-0.7198 2.4e-3 1.7e-4 n/a n/a simple update (fPEPS)
peer reviewed
Liu et al. (2025) 2025
-0.7169 5.2e-3 1.7e-4 n/a n/a simple update (fPEPS)
peer reviewed
Liu et al. (2025) 2025
-0.7162 6.0e-3 2.8e-4 n/a n/a simple update (fPEPS)
peer reviewed
Liu et al. (2025) 2025
-0.7160 6.1e-3 6.8e-4 n/a n/a simple update (fPEPS)
peer reviewed
Liu et al. (2025) 2025
-0.7157 6.5e-3 2.7e-4 n/a n/a simple update (fPEPS)
peer reviewed
Liu et al. (2025) 2025
-0.7141 8.0e-3 2.1e-4 n/a n/a simple update (fPEPS)
peer reviewed
Liu et al. (2025) 2025
-0.7129 9.3e-3 1.2e-4 n/a n/a simple update (fPEPS)
peer reviewed
Liu et al. (2025) 2025
-0.7107 1.1e-2 2.7e-4 n/a n/a simple update (fPEPS)
peer reviewed
Liu et al. (2025) 2025
-0.7066 1.6e-2 4.2e-4 n/a n/a simple update (fPEPS)
peer reviewed
Liu et al. (2025) 2025
-0.7059 1.6e-2 3.6e-4 n/a n/a simple update (fPEPS)
peer reviewed
Liu et al. (2025) 2025
-0.6984 2.4e-2 4.6e-4 n/a n/a simple update (fPEPS)
peer reviewed
Liu et al. (2025) 2025
-0.6977 2.4e-2 4.5e-4 n/a n/a simple update (fPEPS)
peer reviewed
Liu et al. (2025) 2025
-0.6854 3.7e-2 3.4e-4 n/a n/a simple update (fPEPS)
peer reviewed
Liu et al. (2025) 2025
-0.6841 3.8e-2 2.1e-4 n/a n/a simple update (fPEPS)
peer reviewed
Liu et al. (2025) 2025
-0.6479 7.4e-2 5.1e-4 n/a n/a simple update (fPEPS)
peer reviewed
Liu et al. (2025) 2025
-0.6440 7.8e-2 5.1e-4 n/a n/a simple update (fPEPS)
peer reviewed
Liu et al. (2025) 2025

How these numbers were read

Where each number below was read, and how it was checked.

-0.72212, VMC (transformer BF)

Checked 2026-11-10 · source text of arXiv:2507.02644 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading

Reported as. -0.72212

Supplementary Table 2, row NQS, column 16 × 12; dl/gu-si.txt line 120 (pass 2026-10-22-quoted); no error bar | Energy per site in units of t, pure Hubbard model (t' = 0), U = 8, OBC per the Supplementary Table 2 caption. Hole doping 1/8: not printed in the table, but the main text compares 'directly' with the PEPS of Liu et al. (Ref. 48), and the table's PEPS and DMRG cells equal QMBL's rows of Liu et al. at delta = 1/8 on the same lattices (8 cells, e.g. 8 × 8 PEPS -0.69928(3), 16 × 8 DMRG -0.71250). Lx x Ly as printed; QMBL's rectangular lattices put the shorter side first. No error bar printed. Version read: journal Supplementary Information (41467_2026_74028_MOESM1_ESM.pdf); the arXiv text has no such table.

-0.7202(2), simple update (fPEPS)

Checked 2026-11-09 · source text of arXiv:2502.13454 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading

Reported as. -0.72024 (MC error 2.30E-4)

data release https://github.com/LiuWenyuan-Phy/2d-hubbard-data-fpeps-PRL2025, Fig3c_Energy10x16_12x16_16x16.txt, Fig. 3(c), 12 × 16, Ne = 168, D = 20, column VertStripe; line 37 | H = -t sum_<ij>,s (c+ c + h.c.) + U sum n_up n_dn (PRL Eq. 1), t = 1, U = 8; open boundary conditions along both x and y; energies per site. fPEPS: simple update (SU) and gradient optimisation (GO) with Monte Carlo sampling, error = Monte Carlo sampling error; DMRG: SU(2) DMRG (block2) at m multiplets, m = infinity extrapolated in the truncated (discarded) weight.

-0.7201(3), simple update (fPEPS)

Checked 2026-11-09 · source text of arXiv:2502.13454 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading

Reported as. -0.72014 (MC error 3.32E-4)

data release https://github.com/LiuWenyuan-Phy/2d-hubbard-data-fpeps-PRL2025, Fig3c_Energy10x16_12x16_16x16.txt, Fig. 3(c), 12 × 16, Ne = 168, D = 18, column VertStripe; line 36 | H = -t sum_<ij>,s (c+ c + h.c.) + U sum n_up n_dn (PRL Eq. 1), t = 1, U = 8; open boundary conditions along both x and y; energies per site. fPEPS: simple update (SU) and gradient optimisation (GO) with Monte Carlo sampling, error = Monte Carlo sampling error; DMRG: SU(2) DMRG (block2) at m multiplets, m = infinity extrapolated in the truncated (discarded) weight.

-0.7198(2), simple update (fPEPS)

Checked 2026-11-09 · source text of arXiv:2502.13454 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading

Reported as. -0.71975 (MC error 1.69E-4)

data release https://github.com/LiuWenyuan-Phy/2d-hubbard-data-fpeps-PRL2025, Fig3c_Energy10x16_12x16_16x16.txt, Fig. 3(c), 12 × 16, Ne = 168, D = 16, column VertStripe; line 35 | H = -t sum_<ij>,s (c+ c + h.c.) + U sum n_up n_dn (PRL Eq. 1), t = 1, U = 8; open boundary conditions along both x and y; energies per site. fPEPS: simple update (SU) and gradient optimisation (GO) with Monte Carlo sampling, error = Monte Carlo sampling error; DMRG: SU(2) DMRG (block2) at m multiplets, m = infinity extrapolated in the truncated (discarded) weight.

-0.7169(2), simple update (fPEPS)

Checked 2026-11-09 · source text of arXiv:2502.13454 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading

Reported as. -0.71690 (MC error 1.75E-4)

data release https://github.com/LiuWenyuan-Phy/2d-hubbard-data-fpeps-PRL2025, Fig3c_Energy10x16_12x16_16x16.txt, Fig. 3(c), 12 × 16, Ne = 168, D = 14, column VertStripe; line 34 | H = -t sum_<ij>,s (c+ c + h.c.) + U sum n_up n_dn (PRL Eq. 1), t = 1, U = 8; open boundary conditions along both x and y; energies per site. fPEPS: simple update (SU) and gradient optimisation (GO) with Monte Carlo sampling, error = Monte Carlo sampling error; DMRG: SU(2) DMRG (block2) at m multiplets, m = infinity extrapolated in the truncated (discarded) weight.

-0.7162(3), simple update (fPEPS)

Checked 2026-11-09 · source text of arXiv:2502.13454 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading

Reported as. -0.71616 (MC error 2.78E-4)

data release https://github.com/LiuWenyuan-Phy/2d-hubbard-data-fpeps-PRL2025, Fig3c_Energy10x16_12x16_16x16.txt, Fig. 3(c), 12 × 16, Ne = 168, D = 20, column HoriStripe; line 37 | H = -t sum_<ij>,s (c+ c + h.c.) + U sum n_up n_dn (PRL Eq. 1), t = 1, U = 8; open boundary conditions along both x and y; energies per site. fPEPS: simple update (SU) and gradient optimisation (GO) with Monte Carlo sampling, error = Monte Carlo sampling error; DMRG: SU(2) DMRG (block2) at m multiplets, m = infinity extrapolated in the truncated (discarded) weight.

-0.7160(7), simple update (fPEPS)

Checked 2026-11-09 · source text of arXiv:2502.13454 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading

Reported as. -0.71602 (MC error 6.78E-4)

data release https://github.com/LiuWenyuan-Phy/2d-hubbard-data-fpeps-PRL2025, Fig3c_Energy10x16_12x16_16x16.txt, Fig. 3(c), 12 × 16, Ne = 168, D = 18, column HoriStripe; line 36 | H = -t sum_<ij>,s (c+ c + h.c.) + U sum n_up n_dn (PRL Eq. 1), t = 1, U = 8; open boundary conditions along both x and y; energies per site. fPEPS: simple update (SU) and gradient optimisation (GO) with Monte Carlo sampling, error = Monte Carlo sampling error; DMRG: SU(2) DMRG (block2) at m multiplets, m = infinity extrapolated in the truncated (discarded) weight.

-0.7157(3), simple update (fPEPS)

Checked 2026-11-09 · source text of arXiv:2502.13454 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading

Reported as. -0.71566 (MC error 2.69E-4)

data release https://github.com/LiuWenyuan-Phy/2d-hubbard-data-fpeps-PRL2025, Fig3c_Energy10x16_12x16_16x16.txt, Fig. 3(c), 12 × 16, Ne = 168, D = 16, column HoriStripe; line 35 | H = -t sum_<ij>,s (c+ c + h.c.) + U sum n_up n_dn (PRL Eq. 1), t = 1, U = 8; open boundary conditions along both x and y; energies per site. fPEPS: simple update (SU) and gradient optimisation (GO) with Monte Carlo sampling, error = Monte Carlo sampling error; DMRG: SU(2) DMRG (block2) at m multiplets, m = infinity extrapolated in the truncated (discarded) weight.

-0.7141(2), simple update (fPEPS)

Checked 2026-11-09 · source text of arXiv:2502.13454 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading

Reported as. -0.71414 (MC error 2.13E-4)

data release https://github.com/LiuWenyuan-Phy/2d-hubbard-data-fpeps-PRL2025, Fig3c_Energy10x16_12x16_16x16.txt, Fig. 3(c), 12 × 16, Ne = 168, D = 14, column HoriStripe; line 34 | H = -t sum_<ij>,s (c+ c + h.c.) + U sum n_up n_dn (PRL Eq. 1), t = 1, U = 8; open boundary conditions along both x and y; energies per site. fPEPS: simple update (SU) and gradient optimisation (GO) with Monte Carlo sampling, error = Monte Carlo sampling error; DMRG: SU(2) DMRG (block2) at m multiplets, m = infinity extrapolated in the truncated (discarded) weight.

-0.7129(1), simple update (fPEPS)

Checked 2026-11-09 · source text of arXiv:2502.13454 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading

Reported as. -0.71286 (MC error 1.18E-4)

data release https://github.com/LiuWenyuan-Phy/2d-hubbard-data-fpeps-PRL2025, Fig3c_Energy10x16_12x16_16x16.txt, Fig. 3(c), 12 × 16, Ne = 168, D = 12, column VertStripe; line 33 | H = -t sum_<ij>,s (c+ c + h.c.) + U sum n_up n_dn (PRL Eq. 1), t = 1, U = 8; open boundary conditions along both x and y; energies per site. fPEPS: simple update (SU) and gradient optimisation (GO) with Monte Carlo sampling, error = Monte Carlo sampling error; DMRG: SU(2) DMRG (block2) at m multiplets, m = infinity extrapolated in the truncated (discarded) weight.

-0.7107(3), simple update (fPEPS)

Checked 2026-11-09 · source text of arXiv:2502.13454 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading

Reported as. -0.71070 (MC error 2.71E-4)

data release https://github.com/LiuWenyuan-Phy/2d-hubbard-data-fpeps-PRL2025, Fig3c_Energy10x16_12x16_16x16.txt, Fig. 3(c), 12 × 16, Ne = 168, D = 12, column HoriStripe; line 33 | H = -t sum_<ij>,s (c+ c + h.c.) + U sum n_up n_dn (PRL Eq. 1), t = 1, U = 8; open boundary conditions along both x and y; energies per site. fPEPS: simple update (SU) and gradient optimisation (GO) with Monte Carlo sampling, error = Monte Carlo sampling error; DMRG: SU(2) DMRG (block2) at m multiplets, m = infinity extrapolated in the truncated (discarded) weight.

-0.7066(4), simple update (fPEPS)

Checked 2026-11-09 · source text of arXiv:2502.13454 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading

Reported as. -0.70659 (MC error 4.18E-4)

data release https://github.com/LiuWenyuan-Phy/2d-hubbard-data-fpeps-PRL2025, Fig3c_Energy10x16_12x16_16x16.txt, Fig. 3(c), 12 × 16, Ne = 168, D = 10, column VertStripe; line 32 | H = -t sum_<ij>,s (c+ c + h.c.) + U sum n_up n_dn (PRL Eq. 1), t = 1, U = 8; open boundary conditions along both x and y; energies per site. fPEPS: simple update (SU) and gradient optimisation (GO) with Monte Carlo sampling, error = Monte Carlo sampling error; DMRG: SU(2) DMRG (block2) at m multiplets, m = infinity extrapolated in the truncated (discarded) weight.

-0.7059(4), simple update (fPEPS)

Checked 2026-11-09 · source text of arXiv:2502.13454 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading

Reported as. -0.70586 (MC error 3.63E-4)

data release https://github.com/LiuWenyuan-Phy/2d-hubbard-data-fpeps-PRL2025, Fig3c_Energy10x16_12x16_16x16.txt, Fig. 3(c), 12 × 16, Ne = 168, D = 10, column HoriStripe; line 32 | H = -t sum_<ij>,s (c+ c + h.c.) + U sum n_up n_dn (PRL Eq. 1), t = 1, U = 8; open boundary conditions along both x and y; energies per site. fPEPS: simple update (SU) and gradient optimisation (GO) with Monte Carlo sampling, error = Monte Carlo sampling error; DMRG: SU(2) DMRG (block2) at m multiplets, m = infinity extrapolated in the truncated (discarded) weight.

-0.6984(5), simple update (fPEPS)

Checked 2026-11-09 · source text of arXiv:2502.13454 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading

Reported as. -0.69835 (MC error 4.63E-4)

data release https://github.com/LiuWenyuan-Phy/2d-hubbard-data-fpeps-PRL2025, Fig3c_Energy10x16_12x16_16x16.txt, Fig. 3(c), 12 × 16, Ne = 168, D = 8, column VertStripe; line 31 | H = -t sum_<ij>,s (c+ c + h.c.) + U sum n_up n_dn (PRL Eq. 1), t = 1, U = 8; open boundary conditions along both x and y; energies per site. fPEPS: simple update (SU) and gradient optimisation (GO) with Monte Carlo sampling, error = Monte Carlo sampling error; DMRG: SU(2) DMRG (block2) at m multiplets, m = infinity extrapolated in the truncated (discarded) weight.

-0.6977(5), simple update (fPEPS)

Checked 2026-11-09 · source text of arXiv:2502.13454 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading

Reported as. -0.69771 (MC error 4.55E-4)

data release https://github.com/LiuWenyuan-Phy/2d-hubbard-data-fpeps-PRL2025, Fig3c_Energy10x16_12x16_16x16.txt, Fig. 3(c), 12 × 16, Ne = 168, D = 8, column HoriStripe; line 31 | H = -t sum_<ij>,s (c+ c + h.c.) + U sum n_up n_dn (PRL Eq. 1), t = 1, U = 8; open boundary conditions along both x and y; energies per site. fPEPS: simple update (SU) and gradient optimisation (GO) with Monte Carlo sampling, error = Monte Carlo sampling error; DMRG: SU(2) DMRG (block2) at m multiplets, m = infinity extrapolated in the truncated (discarded) weight.

-0.6854(3), simple update (fPEPS)

Checked 2026-11-09 · source text of arXiv:2502.13454 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading

Reported as. -0.68536 (MC error 3.44E-4)

data release https://github.com/LiuWenyuan-Phy/2d-hubbard-data-fpeps-PRL2025, Fig3c_Energy10x16_12x16_16x16.txt, Fig. 3(c), 12 × 16, Ne = 168, D = 6, column VertStripe; line 30 | H = -t sum_<ij>,s (c+ c + h.c.) + U sum n_up n_dn (PRL Eq. 1), t = 1, U = 8; open boundary conditions along both x and y; energies per site. fPEPS: simple update (SU) and gradient optimisation (GO) with Monte Carlo sampling, error = Monte Carlo sampling error; DMRG: SU(2) DMRG (block2) at m multiplets, m = infinity extrapolated in the truncated (discarded) weight.

-0.6841(2), simple update (fPEPS)

Checked 2026-11-09 · source text of arXiv:2502.13454 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading

Reported as. -0.68410 (MC error 2.12E-4)

data release https://github.com/LiuWenyuan-Phy/2d-hubbard-data-fpeps-PRL2025, Fig3c_Energy10x16_12x16_16x16.txt, Fig. 3(c), 12 × 16, Ne = 168, D = 6, column HoriStripe; line 30 | H = -t sum_<ij>,s (c+ c + h.c.) + U sum n_up n_dn (PRL Eq. 1), t = 1, U = 8; open boundary conditions along both x and y; energies per site. fPEPS: simple update (SU) and gradient optimisation (GO) with Monte Carlo sampling, error = Monte Carlo sampling error; DMRG: SU(2) DMRG (block2) at m multiplets, m = infinity extrapolated in the truncated (discarded) weight.

-0.6479(5), simple update (fPEPS)

Checked 2026-11-09 · source text of arXiv:2502.13454 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading

Reported as. -0.64787 (MC error 5.15E-4)

data release https://github.com/LiuWenyuan-Phy/2d-hubbard-data-fpeps-PRL2025, Fig3c_Energy10x16_12x16_16x16.txt, Fig. 3(c), 12 × 16, Ne = 168, D = 4, column VertStripe; line 29 | H = -t sum_<ij>,s (c+ c + h.c.) + U sum n_up n_dn (PRL Eq. 1), t = 1, U = 8; open boundary conditions along both x and y; energies per site. fPEPS: simple update (SU) and gradient optimisation (GO) with Monte Carlo sampling, error = Monte Carlo sampling error; DMRG: SU(2) DMRG (block2) at m multiplets, m = infinity extrapolated in the truncated (discarded) weight.

-0.6440(5), simple update (fPEPS)

Checked 2026-11-09 · source text of arXiv:2502.13454 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading

Reported as. -0.64397 (MC error 5.10E-4)

data release https://github.com/LiuWenyuan-Phy/2d-hubbard-data-fpeps-PRL2025, Fig3c_Energy10x16_12x16_16x16.txt, Fig. 3(c), 12 × 16, Ne = 168, D = 4, column HoriStripe; line 29 | H = -t sum_<ij>,s (c+ c + h.c.) + U sum n_up n_dn (PRL Eq. 1), t = 1, U = 8; open boundary conditions along both x and y; energies per site. fPEPS: simple update (SU) and gradient optimisation (GO) with Monte Carlo sampling, error = Monte Carlo sampling error; DMRG: SU(2) DMRG (block2) at m multiplets, m = infinity extrapolated in the truncated (discarded) weight.

Coverage

Newest published number here: 2026. Literature last checked 2026-11-11 (citation screen of ketboard-hubbard: citing works from OpenAlex and Semantic Scholar (scripts/cited_by.mjs)): 5 papers read, 0 of them with an energy on this page.

This instance as data

JSON · source file on GitHub · add a result · open an issue about this instance