{
  "model": "TFIsing",
  "lattice": "square",
  "n_sites": 16,
  "boundary": "O",
  "params": {
    "h": 1
  },
  "cluster": "4 x 4 square lattice, open boundaries in both directions (arXiv:2510.20063: 'a two-dimensional square lattice of side length Lx = Ly (L = Lx^2 total sites) with open boundary conditions', Table 2: 'the 4×4 TFI model')",
  "instance_id": "TFIsing/square_16_O_1",
  "rows": [
    {
      "energy": -26.8605046395278,
      "sigma": null,
      "energy_variance": null,
      "dof": 16,
      "einf": 0,
      "v_score": null,
      "method": "ED",
      "ansatz": null,
      "method_detail": "",
      "method_as_published": "Exact diagonalization",
      "family": "other",
      "bound_type": "exact",
      "bound_type_reason": "Lanczos exact diagonalization of the full 2^16-state space, computed by QMBL; deterministic",
      "reference": "QMBL, checks/tfising-4x4-open-ed/ (exact diagonalization of the open 4x4 transverse-field Ising square at h = 1, two codes)",
      "peer_reviewed": false,
      "source": "qmbl-verify-2026-11-13",
      "provenance": "primary",
      "verified": {
        "checked_on": "2026-11-13",
        "method": "ed_tfim_4x4.py (code A: scipy.sparse Hamiltonian with ARPACK eigsh, true residual 2.80e-14; code B: matrix-free Lanczos with full reorthogonalisation, residual 2.89e-14), full space of 65,536 states, no symmetry, numpy 2.5.3 and scipy 1.18.1 on an AMD EPYC 9654 server, 2026-11-13; results in checks/tfising-4x4-open-ed/results.txt",
        "reported_as": "-26.86050463952785 (code A) | -26.860504639527853 (code B)",
        "note": "Total energy, H = - sum_<ij> sz_i sz_j - h sum_i sx_i (Pauli matrices) on the open 4x4 lattice (24 bonds), h = 1; E/N = -1.678781540. No published exact energy is carried for this instance; the two codes agree to 3.55e-15. The block-MPS reference of Dektor et al. (Table 2), −26.86050464, lies 4.7e-10 below (inside its printed digits; the first excited level, −26.86046483 in the same table, lies 4.0e-5 above).",
        "secondary_of": null,
        "second_read": {
          "checked_on": "2026-11-16",
          "scope": "value",
          "method": "independent recompute: ed_lib.mjs Lanczos (node, qmbl-verify 2026-09-15 code), full 2^16-state space, no symmetry, open 4x4 grid with 24 bonds, H = - sum sz sz - h sum sx (Pauli); a third code next to the two in checks/tfising-4x4-open-ed",
          "location": "qmbl-runs/qmbl-verify-2026-11-16-frustrated/out/RE-exact-recompute/result.json",
          "reported_as": "-26.860504639528013",
          "conversion": "none (total energy)",
          "note": "agrees to 2.1e-13 (residual 6.9e-13, 80 Lanczos steps)",
          "source_entry": "RE-exact-recompute#0 (qmbl-verify 2026-11-16)"
        }
      },
      "computed_by": "qmbl",
      "corrections": [
        {
          "field": "verified.note",
          "reported_as": "-26.86050463952785 (code A) | -26.860504639527853 (code B); Dektor et al. Table 2 '−26.86050464'",
          "location": "qmbl/checks/tfising-4x4-open-ed/results.txt h=1.0; arXiv:2510.20063v1 Table 2 row g = 1.0, α = 0",
          "version_read": "qmbl/checks/tfising-4x4-open-ed/ed_tfim_4x4.py and results.txt (read only; no ED run on this machine)",
          "conversion": "-26.86050464 - (-26.86050463952785) = -4.72e-10",
          "checked_on": "2026-11-16",
          "reason": "Arithmetic slip in the note text only; the energy is right. The other three notes (4.1e-10, 2.8e-9, 6.4e-9 above) check out.",
          "source_entry": "RP2-heisenberg-tfising#32 (qmbl-verify 2026-11-16)",
          "edit": [
            "lies 3.5e-10 below",
            "lies 4.7e-10 below"
          ],
          "from": "Total energy, H = - sum_<ij> sz_i sz_j - h sum_i sx_i (Pauli matrices) on the open 4x4 lattice (24 bonds), h = 1; E/N = -1.678781540. No published exact energy is carried for this instance; the two codes agree to 3.55e-15. The block-MPS reference of Dektor et al. (Table 2), −26.86050464, lies 3.5e-10 below (inside its printed digits; the first excited level, −26.86046483 in the same table, lies 4.0e-5 above).",
          "to": "Total energy, H = - sum_<ij> sz_i sz_j - h sum_i sx_i (Pauli matrices) on the open 4x4 lattice (24 bonds), h = 1; E/N = -1.678781540. No published exact energy is carried for this instance; the two codes agree to 3.55e-15. The block-MPS reference of Dektor et al. (Table 2), −26.86050464, lies 4.7e-10 below (inside its printed digits; the first excited level, −26.86046483 in the same table, lies 4.0e-5 above)."
        }
      ],
      "artifacts": {
        "code": "https://github.com/quantum-many-body-leaderboard/quantum-many-body-leaderboard/tree/4d76524a/checks/tfising-4x4-open-ed",
        "commit": "4d76524a",
        "script": "checks/tfising-4x4-open-ed/",
        "read_from": {
          "quote": "QMBL, checks/tfising-4x4-open-ed/ (exact diagonalization of the open 4x4 transverse-field Ising square at h = 1, two codes)",
          "location": "the row's reference (QMBL check directory)",
          "checked_on": "2026-11-13",
          "pass": "passes/code/code-links-2026-11-13.json"
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "energy": -26.86050464,
      "sigma": null,
      "energy_variance": null,
      "dof": 16,
      "einf": 0,
      "v_score": null,
      "method": "DMRG",
      "ansatz": null,
      "method_detail": "block MPS alternating optimization, bond dimension up to 5000",
      "method_as_published": "block MPS alternating optimization (reference, bond dimension up to 5000)",
      "family": "tensor network",
      "bound_type": "variational",
      "bound_type_reason": "variational ansatz at a stated size; energy is an upper bound (assigned during source reading)",
      "reference": "Dektor, Chi, Van Beeumen & Yang, Computing excited states with isometric tensor networks in two-dimensions, arXiv:2510.20063",
      "peer_reviewed": false,
      "source": "sweep-allresults-2026-11-12",
      "provenance": "primary",
      "verified": {
        "checked_on": "2026-11-12",
        "method": "source text of arXiv:2510.20063 read locally (arXiv HTML or pypdf layout text); value copied from the harvested cell and the text, no LLM transcription of numbers; single reading (2026-11-12)",
        "reported_as": "−26.86050464",
        "note": "Table 2, row g = 1, α = 0 (ground state), column 'reference'; 'With a maximum bond dimension of 5000, reference energies for the TFI model were obtained with relative accuracy of order 10−6 for Lx ≤ 8' (Sec. 5); sources/2510.20063.txt line 824; version read: arXiv 2510.20063v1 text (sources/2510.20063.txt); no journal version (arXiv metadata, 2026-11-12) | Eq. (34): H_TFI = − sum_<i,j> σz_i σz_j − g sum_i σx_i (Pauli matrices), the instance's Hamiltonian with h = g; Table 2 prints total energies of the 4 x 4 cluster, converted here to per site (/16).",
        "secondary_of": null,
        "second_read": {
          "checked_on": "2026-11-16",
          "scope": "value",
          "method": "arXiv:2510.20063v1 (only version; abs page 2026-11-16 shows no journal reference), cached text qmbl/sources/2510.20063.txt read with grep -a (the file carries non-UTF-8 bytes)",
          "location": "Table 2, row g = 1, α = 0, column 'reference' (arXiv v1 p. 14; text line 824)",
          "reported_as": "−26.86050464",
          "conversion": "printed total energy, stored as printed: -26.86050464",
          "note": "Eq. (34) H_TFI = − Σ_<i,j> σz_i σz_j − g Σ_i σx_i with 'Pauli matrices', on 'a two-dimensional square lattice of side length Lx = Ly ... with open boundary conditions' (Sec. 5): QMBL's TFIsing with h = g, open on all four sides; Table 2 prints total energies of the '4×4 TFI model' (−57.8 for 16 sites). What the reference is (brief question 5): 'reference eigenvalues E_α,ref for the TFI model (34) were computed using the block MPS alternating optimization algorithm described in [23]' ([23] = Dolgov, Khoromskij, Oseledets & Savostyanov, Comput. Phys. Commun. 185, 1207 (2014)); 'With a maximum bond dimension of 5000, reference energies for the TFI model were obtained with relative accuracy of order 10−6 for Lx ≤ 8'. It is a variational MPS energy, not an exact reference; on 4 x 4 the bond dimension cap 5000 exceeds the largest Schmidt rank 2^8 = 256, so the MPS can represent the state exactly. Against QMBL's ED (-26.86050463952785): printed − ED = -4.72e-10, i.e. the printed value lies 4.7e-10 below exact, inside its eighth-decimal rounding (tolerance 5e-9); not a bound violation. bound_type variational is right; peer_reviewed false (v1 only). The α = 1 cells are excited states, not rows. Not a duplicate of the exact row (different source and computation). Record row (best variational).",
          "source_entry": "RP2-heisenberg-tfising#36 (qmbl-verify 2026-11-16)"
        }
      }
    }
  ],
  "url": "https://qmbl.org/i/TFIsing/square_16_O_1/",
  "per_site_divisor": 16,
  "per_site_label": "E/N (Pauli)",
  "best": {
    "exact": {
      "energy": -26.8605046395278,
      "sigma": null,
      "method": "ED",
      "ansatz": null,
      "method_detail": "",
      "reference": "QMBL, checks/tfising-4x4-open-ed/ (exact diagonalization of the open 4x4 transverse-field Ising square at h = 1, two codes)",
      "bound_type": "exact",
      "energy_per_site": -1.6787815399704875
    },
    "variational": {
      "energy": -26.86050464,
      "sigma": null,
      "method": "DMRG",
      "ansatz": null,
      "method_detail": "block MPS alternating optimization, bond dimension up to 5000",
      "reference": "Dektor, Chi, Van Beeumen & Yang, Computing excited states with isometric tensor networks in two-dimensions, arXiv:2510.20063",
      "bound_type": "variational",
      "energy_per_site": -1.67878154
    },
    "projected": null,
    "extrapolated": null,
    "approximate": null,
    "below_exact": []
  },
  "no_best_reason": null,
  "record": {
    "energy": -26.8605046395278,
    "sigma": null,
    "method": "ED",
    "ansatz": null,
    "method_detail": "",
    "reference": "QMBL, checks/tfising-4x4-open-ed/ (exact diagonalization of the open 4x4 transverse-field Ising square at h = 1, two codes)",
    "bound_type": "exact",
    "energy_per_site": -1.6787815399704875
  },
  "no_record_reason": null
}
